Gaza’s worst fear is no longer bombs but ‘humanitarian cities’

We thought returning home would end the nightmare.

After months of fleeing bombardment, sleeping in tents, schools, or under makeshift nylon sheets, many families finally walked back to their homes in northern Gaza during the fragile ceasefire in January 2025. The roads were lined with rubble. Our houses were broken shells, neighbourhoods unrecognisable. Yet we carried a fragile hope: that by stepping back onto our land, even among ruins, we were reclaiming our lives.

But as soon as we returned, the headlines followed us. Terms like “mass relocations”, “humanitarian cities,” and “population transfers” began to appear, suggesting that even after everything we had endured, our next destination might not be what remains of our homes, but military-controlled camps in the far south of Gaza, where the army had swept through and wiped out entire residential neighbourhoods, turning them into barren, flattened deserts.

For many outside Gaza, such reports read as distant political debates. For us, they land like threats. Each new statement feels like a draft of our next exile. The idea that the Israeli military might herd hundreds of thousands of us is terrifying precisely because we know what those “cities” would really be: overcrowded compounds, controlled checkpoints, food and water distribution under armed watch — if we are lucky enough to receive them — no freedom of movement, no guarantee of ever leaving.

Families who have just swept dust from their broken floors now whisper about whether they should keep bags half-packed, ready to flee once again. Children, who have barely adjusted to sleeping in their own beds after months away, overhear the word “relocation” and start crying. We all know what it means: another round of humiliation, another erasure of what little normal life we are trying to piece together.

Meanwhile, life in northern Gaza is already unbearably hard. Water and electricity are scarce. Food is overpriced and often unavailable. Families live among rubble, patching holes with nylon sheets. Yet even in these conditions, people cling to the dignity of being on their own land.

But that fragile dignity is overshadowed by the possibility that it could all vanish. Every attempt to rebuild — a repaired roof, a replanted garden, a reopened shop — feels provisional. Parents ask themselves: Should we invest in repairing the house if we may be forced out again? Students sit with books by candlelight yet wonder: What school will I graduate from if we are moved tomorrow? Every moment of normality feels as though it could be interrupted by soldiers demanding we leave.

What would it mean to live in these camps? The very thought keeps us awake at night.

We picture long queues for food, dependent on ration cards for every meal. We imagine tents lined in rows, stripped of privacy, where families huddle with strangers and women fear for safety in overcrowded conditions. We imagine soldiers controlling the gates, deciding who enters and who leaves, monitoring our lives with cameras and watchtowers.

For children, it would mean growing up without classrooms they know, without streets that carry their memories. Their “playground” would be a fenced dirt lot. For young men and women, it would mean the end of any chance at education or work; for, inside camps, life shrinks to survival. For the elderly, it would mean dying away from what remains of the houses and trees they planted with their own hands.

These are not abstract fears; they match what has already been documented in displacement zones and what legal experts predict. Analysts writing for JURIST and the Council on Foreign Relations note that once inside such camps, Palestinians would be unable to leave freely, their movements tightly monitored, their lives dependent on aid distribution. The United Nations agencies and NGOs have also warned that further mass relocations under military oversight could constitute forcible transfer.

The danger of these proposals is not only the physical hardship but the permanence they suggest. History has taught us that once people are forced into camps, “temporary” becomes long-term. A tent pitched “for now” becomes a marker of exile for decades.

That is why the fear today feels heavier than even the destruction we have endured. Bombs destroy cities, but forced relocation destroys roots. If we are pushed into these camps, it will not just be the loss of homes; it will be the loss of any claim to return.

Satellite imagery already confirms this danger is not theoretical. In Rafah, Al Jazeera’s Sanad agency documented the destruction of nearly 30,000 buildings between April and July 2025, providing evidence of land-clearing consistent with preparations for such a “humanitarian city”.

What makes this looming threat unbearable is the trajectory of our lives. We have already been pushed from hard to harder: from homes to schools, from schools to tents, from tents back to broken houses. And now, the plan being whispered is the hardest yet — military-run shelters that strip us of autonomy altogether.

What we really fear is not paranoia. It is a recurring project to erase us from our land. Some may wonder why the idea of relocation is more terrifying than the bombs we have survived. The reason is simple: bombs destroy walls, steal lives, but they do not sever us from our land. Forced relocation uproots us forever.

To lose a home is devastating. To lose the possibility of return is annihilating. That is why families whisper about the proposals with trembling voices. Because deep down, we know: once we are herded there, we may never see home again.

The world must see through the language being used. The term “humanitarian” is a mask. What is being proposed is not relief but imprisonment. What is being prepared is not shelter but a system of control designed to make displacement permanent.

If you read those headlines, do not imagine children playing safely in neat new towns. Imagine them staring through barbed wire, asking why they cannot go home. Imagine mothers queueing for a ration of flour under the eyes of soldiers. Imagine fathers pacing at night, unable to protect their families from the indignity of being treated as captives.

For us in Gaza, the worst may still be ahead. We returned home believing the nightmare was beginning to end. Instead, we live in the shadow of a new displacement, one that could erase even the ruins we call ours. This is the horror that defines our present: not only surviving bombardment, but living every day with the dread that the next chapter is already written, that the hardest chapter is still to come.

More than 300 South Korean workers return home after US immigration raid

A chartered flight carrying hundreds of South Korean workers arrested in a major United States immigration raid has landed in Incheon, ending a weeklong saga that rattled Seoul and cast a dark shadow over its ties with key ally Washington.

Television footage showed a Korean Air Boeing 747-8I touching down at Incheon International Airport on Friday with more than 310 passengers who had been arrested in the US state of Georgia.

Recommended Stories

list of 3 itemsend of list

The workers made up the bulk of the 475 people swept up during a raid at a Hyundai-LG battery plant construction site – the largest single-site immigration operation since US President Donald Trump resumed office and pledged to intensify crackdowns.

“Everything at Atlanta went smoothly,” a South Korean Foreign Ministry official told the AFP news agency, confirming the flight left as scheduled.

Images of workers in handcuffs and chains during the arrests caused deep outrage in South Korea, where anger has spread over what many see as a betrayal of an ally.

At the airport, protesters held placards mocking Trump in an ICE uniform and accusing Washington of luring investment only to criminalise workers. One man’s sign read: “You told us to invest, only to arrest us! Is this how you treat an ally?”

Rare political unity in South Korea

President Lee Jae-mMyung called the raid “bewildering” and warned it could deter future investment. He said Seoul was pressing Washington “to ensure that visa issuance for investment-related purposes operates normally”.

Al Jazeera’s Jack Barton, reporting from Incheon airport, said US officials had insisted “right up until the last moment that they were going to be deported and that there would be restrictions … on re-entry for at least the next five years”.

But, Barton noted, “the South Korean government was able to negotiate with the Trump administration … and they were allowed in the end to [make] a voluntary return, and … there will be no visa restrictions or re-entry restrictions.”

Barton said the raid had caused rare political unity in South Korea. “This is the only issue I’ve seen them really sort of on the same page,” he reported, with politicians from across the spectrum condemning images of workers “having their ankles and hands chained together, and then doing that sort of perp walk onto the bus”.

He added that polls showed at least 60 percent of South Koreans disapproved of the raid, warning the fallout could damage future investments.

Industry executives said the arrests would delay construction at the $4.3bn Georgia facility.

Rescuers search for missing people as deadly Indonesia floods recede

Rescuers have been searching in rivers and the rubble of devastated villages for survivors of deadly flash floods that struck two provinces in Indonesia earlier this week, killing at least 23 people and leaving five missing, as waters began to recede.

Torrential rains for the last four days caused flooding and landslides in nine cities and districts of the tourist island of Bali and in East Nusa Tenggara province. Rising rivers submerged at least 120 neighbourhoods and resulted in a dozen landslides in several places, National Disaster Mitigation Agency spokesperson Abdul Muhari said in a statement on Thursday, with the higher death toll reported by officials on Friday.

Recommended Stories

list of 3 itemsend of list

Muhari said rescuers had retrieved seven more bodies as floods receded in Bali, bringing the death toll from floods on the island to 16. Rescue workers are still searching for a missing resident, he added.

A weeklong state of emergency was declared to mobilise additional resources.

As river levels returned to close to normal on Thursday, people in Denpasar, Bali’s capital, left crammed emergency shelters.

Authorities took advantage of the receding waters to begin clearing mud and removing piles of wet rubbish from the streets, while electricity was restored to tens of thousands of residences and businesses.

Indonesia is prone to flooding and landslides during the rainy season, which typically peaks between November and March. The recent rainfall is considered unusually heavy for September.

Suharyanto, head of the National Disaster Mitigation Agency, told a news conference late Wednesday that the threat of flooding in Bali is over.

He said up to 600 rescue workers, police and soldiers have been deployed since Wednesday to search for people still reported missing in Bali, as the floods have also damaged roads, bridges and other infrastructure.

By late Thursday, about 552 people remained crammed in government shelters in several districts in Bali, the agency said.

“The Indonesian Disaster Mitigation Agency blamed the heavy downpour, the landscape of Bali and tidal activity as the cause of the great flood,” said Al Jazeera’s Valdiya Barapotri, reporting from Badung Regency in Denpasar.

“However, Balinese see that there is more to the issue; the rapid growth overcharged by overtourism and mismanagement of urban planning and waste in Bali are seen as the root of the cause,” said Barapotri, standing before “a ruin of three shops that doubled as homes that collapsed in the flood”, resulting in the deaths of four people.

Barapotri added that, “Rivers and ricefields in Bali [have been] replaced by concrete, therefore Bali lost a lot of water shed and recharge area, so when the rain falls, which happens quite often in this tropical island, Bali is more prone to flooding.”

In East Nusa Tenggara province, dozens of rescuers were searching through a river around the remote village of Mauponggo in Hagekeo district, where floods left tonnes of mud, rocks and trees.

Rescuers on Thursday found the body of a 14-month-old child, one of two toddlers whom rescuers had been searching for, said Muhari. Four other bodies were pulled out of floodwaters or mud on Wednesday.

Local Disaster Mitigation Agency head Agustinus Pone said the severe weather and rugged terrain that hampered rescue efforts were exacerbated by the disruption of electricity, clean water, and telecommunications networks in 18 villages by flash floods.

Dinosaurs to supercrocs: Niger’s bone keepers preserve its ancient fossils

Niamey, Niger – In a corner of the sprawling grounds of Niamey’s only museum – a unique, open-air style arrangement in Niger’s capital that doubles as a zoo – imposing fossil replicas of long-extinct animals stand in a corrugated iron stall.

On a recent late Friday afternoon, the Boubou Hama National Museum was busy with scores of excited children. They shrilled, delighted by the rubbery grunts of the hippos near the replicas, and the faint roars of the lions further up.

Recommended Stories

list of 3 itemsend of list

Laughter floated over to the fossil exhibition, but the replacement bones, made of resin, and which included those of a long-necked dinosaur called a jobaria, its smaller, sail-backed cousin, and a very long crocodile, were largely left alone, save for two men who stopped by for quick selfies.

While living animals today may steal the show, Niger’s fossils represent rare evidence of the life that flourished in this part of the continent before humans. Original bones are stored in a room on the complex to avoid damage and theft, or are housed in museums abroad.

Much of the Sahara, including a vast swath of northern Niger, which lies within the desert, is replete with dinosaur and animal remains like these, waiting to be discovered by scientists who aim to paint a picture of what the world used to look like.

Museum director-general Adouramane Gabidan looks at fossils on display at Boubou Hama National Museum, Niamey [Shola Lawal/Al Jazeera]

“More than a hundred million years ago, can you imagine that?” asks the museum’s director-general, Abdouramane Gabidan, in a wondrous tone, as he looks at the exhibition through the iron railings protecting it.

It’s hard to imagine, he says, that present-day arid Niger was once lush forests and huge water bodies in which vanished animals and, later, civilisations thrived.

Dinosaurs, for one, lived about 252 to 66 million years ago, during a period scientists refer to as the Mesozoic era. Climatic changes, however, after a huge asteroid crashed into Earth, caused a mass extinction event that wiped the creatures out, scientists believe. After dinosaurs, early hunter-gatherer humans co-existed with wildlife in the once-green Sahara.

“People don’t believe it when you say we once had water here,” Gabidan adds. “That’s why it’s so important for our people to see this and be educated on this history.”

Yet, for all the glorious treasures buried in its shifting sands, Niger has been unable to transform its heritage into wealth and cement itself as a global tourist destination for fossil buffs.

Persistent poverty, despite abundant gold and uranium deposits, means successive governments have more pressing priorities than investing in archaeology. Instead, Niger has become a cultural trafficking zone, with ancient bones and artefacts smuggled out to the West and sold for exorbitant prices on black markets.

In the latest case of alleged cultural theft, a rare meteorite originating from the northern Agadez region sold for $4.3m at an auction held by New York’s Sotheby’s in July. Meteorites are pieces of stone that fall to the Earth from outer space.

The military government in Niamey, however, says the stone was likely trafficked, and is now investigating how it left the country.

Extinct animal fossils, including dinosaurs, on display at Bobou Hama National Museum, Niamey
The Bobou Hama National Museum displays fossil replicas of extinct animals, including that of jobaria, a long-necked herbivorous dinosaur [Shola Lawal/Al Jazeera]

Hidden histories in the sands

After millions of years spent buried beneath the earth, fresh fossils look different from what museum-goers gawk at when they are finally displayed. A huge amount of work goes into carefully packaging, transporting, cleaning, and then assembling them. It often requires a large team of scientists and local guides. Sophisticated machines and temperature-controlled storage facilities to keep the delicate fossils from crumbling are also essential. Careful preparation, with special glues and plaster jackets, for example, enables fossils to withstand movement and being displayed. High-quality replicas are sometimes exhibited when the bones are too fragile.

Much of the necessary infrastructure is lacking in Niger, and the country only has a few archaeologists. It’s partly why replicas are displayed, along with security considerations. Expeditions there have often been led by foreign experts, particularly those from France who embedded with the French army during colonial rule between the 1800s and 1960. Late geologist Hugues Faure, for example, is credited with discovering the first deposits of fossils while prospecting for minerals. Palaeontologist Philippe Taquet, meanwhile, found and identified species like the ouranosaurus, a herbivorous dinosaur that resembles an inflated, hump-backed lizard.

Oumarou Amadou Ide, Niger’s leading archaeologist and research director at the Institute of Human Research (IRSH) in Niamey, blames the slow development of local expertise on education – or the lack of it.

It was only in 1974 that Niamey’s Abdou Moumouni University, the oldest public university in Niger, was founded, decades after its counterparts in the region. Archaeology was introduced two years later, but there’s still no palaeontology programme – the branch of geology that focuses specifically on fossils.

Ide, who holds a doctorate in archaeology from Paris’s Sorbonne University, has led excavations of dinosaur fossils and near-intact burial and ritual sites from early civilisations like the Bura-Asinda culture that existed between the 3rd and 13th centuries in western Niger. The Bura site has been so intensely looted of its treasures since its excavation in 1975 that it’s now on a UNESCO endangered sites list.

“Niger is haemorrhaging its national culture,” the professor says.

He faults the authorities’ inability to clamp down on smuggling through Niamey’s Diori Hamani International Airport and establish a commission devoted to safeguarding heritage.

American scientist Paul Sereno, a professor of palaeontology and archaeology at the University of Chicago and head of the university’s Fossil Lab, concurs that the local archaeology framework could be stronger.

Sereno began digging in the country’s north in 1997, working with Nigerien experts like Ide. He has since returned on several more expeditions during which he has uncovered about nine new species of dinosaurs. One of them is the jobaria, the tall herbivore whose replica is caged in the museum hall, and which takes its name from a mythical spirit in local Tuareg folklore. Sereno is also credited with discovering hundreds of human burials, including the skeletons of a mother curled up with two children.

 Jobaria is on public display stimulating numer-ous questions on the part of children and Paul Sereno and his team are happy to answer all questi-ons
The original jobaria on public display in Niamey after it was first excavated by Paul Sereno and his team on December 4, 2000. Some of the original fossils Sereno discovered are kept at the Niamey museum, while many others are housed in his lab in Chicago [File: Didier Dutheil/Sygma via Getty Images]

Speaking to Al Jazeera over a video call, Sereno recounts his latest expedition in 2022, which he says was his most ambitious. A caravan of nearly a hundred people – scientists, his students from Chicago, local guides, and armed Nigerien soldiers with vehicle-mounted machineguns – drove from Niamey deep into the hyperarid Tenere, a stretch of the Sahara in northern Niger. In those parts, archaeologists need armed protection against bandit groups. Some parts of northern Niger are also overrun by armed groups, which operate in border areas with neighbouring Mali and Burkina Faso.

“It was a small army,” Sereno laughs. “That was a bit of overkill, but there’s no roads, there’s no airplanes. You can be in the middle of nowhere, and all of a sudden, you’re going to find somebody. That’s what the desert is like. It’s a wonderful place, but at the same time, you have to bring your security.”

It took the team three weeks of round-the-clock work under the sweltering sun to recover 55 tonnes of fossils. Sereno usually has to ship most of the fossils to Chicago for preservation, but a July 2023 coup and the subsequent government change in Niamey have stalled the latest cargo, meaning the bones are still sitting in air-tight containers waiting to be sent.

Even as Sereno is working to transport the latest fossils to his lab, he’s also planning to bring them, and others he earlier retrieved, back in grand style. The scientist said he is collaborating with local authorities in Niamey and Agadez to build two world-class museums where he plans to display all the fossils he has gathered over the years. Sereno also plans to build educational facilities to train students who can help preserve the bones.

“You need to understand what I have taken at the behest and kindness and graciousness of Niger,” Sereno says. “It’s more fossil material than has ever been taken off the entire continent of Africa. I’ve taken a hundred ancient humans. Of course, they’re all going to go back, but it’s an extraordinary relationship.”

Rachidatou Hassane, an intern at Niamey museum, cleans fossils on display
Rachidatou Hassane, an intern at Niamey museum, cleans fossil replicas on display [Courtesy of Rachidatou Hassane]

The new school of Nigerien experts

As a cultural heritage professor at the Niamey University, museum director Gabidan is often stunned at how little interest some of his students have in the practical aspects of working in museums. Many times, he says, he has to coax them to join him at the Niamey museum so they can get the experience they need.

A few students have, on taking his advice, become inseparable from the complex, Gabidan says. They form part of a growing crop of young people interested in working more closely on fossils.

In the central part of the Niamey University campus, Rachidatou Hassane, one of Gabidan’s best students, sits under a shade of trees, chatting with classmates. Hassane first landed an internship at the museum-zoo about three years ago, with no particular field of interest in mind.

Somehow, she says, she’d been attracted to the dinosaurs, and would often find herself going back to them. As a student, her work involved cleaning the specimens kept safely away in store rooms, but vulnerable to termites. She was also responsible for cleaning the resin replicas mounted for display.

“My first encounter left me just speechless,” the 28-year-old says. The original bones moved her because they’d managed to survive for so long, she adds. “I was impressed to see how pristine these bones could remain with good conservation treatment.” Each one, Hassane says, seemed to her like a puzzle to decipher, a piece that could reveal decades and centuries of lost histories.

It was about the same time that an international team, led by Sereno, the Chicago professor, was in town to dig up new fossils up north. Rachidatou got to work with the team, assisting with the brushing and careful packaging required for preserving and moving the ancient bones. Her obvious interest caught the Chicago team’s attention. Barely a year later, Sereno’s nonprofit organisation – Niger Heritage – was making arrangements for Rachidatou to travel to the United States for training at his lab.

“It was a whole lot,” laughs Rachidatou now, having just returned to Niamey from her second US trip. She has also had to take English classes to brush up on her grammar, since French is Niger’s national language. If she can get the language skills down, Hassane is set to receive a scholarship for training as a museum conservator. That, though, has been a struggle, she says.

“I stayed with family when I was in the US, and we all spoke French and Hausa, and that did not help at all,” Hassane complains now with a small smile.

But if all goes well, she could soon become Niger’s first female museologist, something she says is now one of her life’s goals.

More students like Hassane will also likely travel to the US for study in the coming years, all part of Sereno’s bid to build local expertise as he prepares to return tonnes of fossils to Niamey.

Niger’s fossils can’t do without some foreign expertise, says Gabidan back at the museum complex as the sun was starting to set and the crowd began to thin out.

The hope, however, is that there will come a time when Niger’s own experts will be so well trained that they will have better influence over how their country’s heritage is preserved.