What’s gone wrong with England’s bowling attack?

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.

  • 633 Comments

The fallout from England’s latest damaging Ashes defeat has, as ever, focused largely on their struggling batters.

Brainless. Unwilling to learn. Reckless. The withering analysis goes on.

But in the second Test there was another concerning failure as a fast bowling attack built for this very moment performed desperately.

Stuart Broad, an all-time great not long out of the dressing room, has labelled England’s first-innings effort with the ball in Brisbane their worst bowling performance since 2008. A wayward start and a bizarrely flat end allowed Australia to canter towards a par score and stroll well beyond it.

Broad is right – that innings was a startling extreme.

But the overall bowling average of Ben Stokes’ side in 2025 is also their worst for 23 years and their sixth worst calendar year in 140 years of Test cricket.

‘The worst performance since 2008’

Those 2025 numbers can, in part, be put down to who and where England have played.

Seven Tests in a row have come against India and Australia, with those India matches all lasting five days on some of the flattest pitches seen in the UK.

England’s only other Test this year was the four-day match against Zimbabwe, played on another slow surface at Trent Bridge, on which spinner Shoaib Bashir took nine wickets.

It is also undeniable an all-pace attack was both thrilling and threatening on first viewing in this Ashes series in bundling Australia out for 135 in Perth.

But that only makes the performances since, particularly the first innings in Brisbane with the game on the line and momentum with them, more disheartening.

“I have not seen a whole group get it wrong and bowl short and wide,” Broad told the Sky Cricket podcast.

CricViz

The numbers were ugly.

Only once had Australia reached 100 quicker in a home Ashes Test while Brydon Carse conceded 95 runs in his first 12 overs. Stokes went for 64 in his first 11.

The number of balls on the ideal hard length (7-8m) dropped from 31% in the first 20 overs in the first innings in Perth to 17% at the Gabba and Australia scored 81 runs off the back foot – the most on record by any team in their first 20 overs of a match and the clearest sign England bowled short and wide.

Broad was not the only legend watching on for the first time in a generation.

“I was just thinking, ‘Pitch it up, just try and pitch it up a bit fuller’,” said James Anderson, whose Ashes contributions now come via the Tailenders podcast having been pushed aside in 2024 for these very bowlers.

Have England picked the wrong attack?

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.

England cannot deny they began this tour with the exact attack they’d have scribbled down on a whiteboard two years ago, more in hope than expectation.

In Brisbane they picked three tall fast bowlers – Jofra Archer, Gus Atkinson and Carse – who thud the ball into the pitch at pace, plus a fully-fit Stokes.

This was their much-discussed plan – backing pace and steep bounce, while ignoring statistics that show bowlers operating below 83mph, who previously averaged eight runs per wicket worse than those reaching speeds above, have wiped out their inferiority in Australia in the past three years on livelier pitches and with the new Kookaburra ball.

Of course, there are caveats here too and, as ever, familiar criticism of the retiring of Anderson has resurfaced.

Chris Woakes’ shoulder injury in the fifth Test against India denied England the option of his nibblers while Essex seamer Sam Cook was overlooked after one underwhelming Test.

At his best, Anderson might have found more change from such surfaces but the 43-year-old played in less than half of Lancashire’s County Championship matches this summer amid injury struggles and averaged 85.40 with the ball against these Australians at home in 2023.

Are this crop simply England’s best Test bowlers, who happen to each be quick?

“They’re the right bowlers,” said former England bowler Steven Finn.

“I’m not sure anyone else in the country would have made a difference.”

Not a pace problem but one of leadership

Brydon Carse, Gus Atkinson, Jofra Archer and Ben Stokes (from left to right)Getty Images

Though six wickets for Michael Neser’s 82mph seam were an uncomfortable contrast at the Gabba, wickets are still falling more regularly to deliveries over 85mph than below in this series.

Archer has been England’s best bowler so far – the one capable of a match-winning spell – and he and Wood, England’s quickest two options before Wood’s series-ending injury, have the produced the highest percentage of false shots from Australian batters.

Despite taking only three wickets, Archer also comes out top of CricViz’s ‘Expected Average’ model across both sides while Mitchell Starc, Australia’s quickest bowler, is two Tests into an iconic Australian summer.

Broad, though, highlighted a deeper issue that could continue to thwart England’s plans.

“[Archer, Carse and Atkinson] don’t strike me as real tacticians of a game – thinkers of the craft,” said Broad on the For The Love of Cricket podcast.

“It struck me there were a lot of times Archer was at mid-on, Atkinson deep cover and Carse bowling. They would not say a word. You have got to work together.

“Stokes has to make all of the decisions along with other captaincy decisions. He is bowling, pouring with sweat and looks like he is taking so much on.

“It is first time he has captained without an experienced bowler.”

Suddenly the absence of Woakes and his 62 Tests of experience looks more significant, even with his history of struggling down under.

Remarkably, with Wood now to return home, 22-year-old Bashir’s 19 Test caps make him the most experienced of any of England’s frontline bowlers on tour.

Hopes Atkinson could grow from his quiet personality and be the attack leader were hit by injuries he suffered in the summer, which meant he only played one of the India Tests.

Archer is the most experienced quick with 17 caps, making his way back after four years out injured.

“That’s not me saying Anderson should be here or Woakes should be here,” added Broad.

“It is one of those things that happens.

“It struck me for the first time in two years that there is no-one helping Stokesy.”

Related topics

  • England Men’s Cricket Team
  • The Ashes
  • Cricket

More on this story

    • 16 August
    BBC Sport microphone and phone

Burden beats Bingham in Shoot Out for first ranking title

Getty Images

Alfie Burden beat Stuart Bingham 63-8 to win the Snooker Shoot Out and claim his first ranking title in Blackpool.

He turns 49 on Sunday but started the celebrations early by climbing on the table to huge cheers once victory was confirmed at Blackpool Tower Circus.

Burden, who won the World Seniors Championship in May, takes home the £50,000 prize.

“I’ve had a 30-year career and it has been mainly downs – I’ve underperformed – but tonight is a night for me,” Burden told TNT Sports.

“I’d like to thank all my family and friends for all the belief they’ve had in me. This is a special moment and I’m going to cherish it.”

Bingham finished runner-up at the Snooker Shoot Out in 2014 but passed up the opportunity to mount a fightback from 56-7 with three minutes on the clock.

The 2015 World Champion put away a red but was well wide of the mark when going at the blue.

“He looked so cool and calm all the way through. He played brilliantly from the start,” Bingham told TNT Sports.

Snooker Shoot Out is a single-frame game with a maximum length of 10 minutes and players facing a shot clock.

Related topics

  • Snooker

Simon Cowell broke down on camera after Liam Payne’s ‘horrific’ death

Music mogul Simon Cowell admits hearing of One Direction star Liam Payne’s death while filming almost lead to him cancelling his new Netflix series The Next Act

Simon Cowell’s new Netflix talent hunt, The Next Act, dropped on the streamer this week – but one “horrific” moment showed the moment he was told about One Direction star Liam Payne’s death. Music mogul Cowell and artist Liam remained close until he tragically died after falling from the balcony of an Argentinian hotel.

But the record label owner was cautious about airing the footage, sending it to the late star’s family and his ex, Cheryl Tweedy, ahead of it being shown on TV. The show sees Simon on the hunt for the next big boyband, following the record-breaking success story of One Direction, but filming was almost cancelled when he found out the heartbreaking news of Liam’s death.

READ MORE: Liam Payne girlfriend sobs as she issues warning to her future boyfriends over late starREAD MORE: ‘Oodie’s weighted blanket kept me warm during a cold spell and has one perk for sleeping’

During the six-part series, Simon said of Liam: “He was just so normal and down to earth, he always had a sparkle in his eye. Everyone adored him. You don’t know how you feel about someone until you lose them. I am going to genuinely miss him.”

Speaking at the launch of the Netflix series, Simon opened up on how he handled the footage, which came as a complete shock to him and the crew. He told the Sun: “In the middle, there was that moment with Liam, which was just horrific. That really threw us.

“I was very close to him, and that was hard. We almost stopped filming. I had to go away, clear my head.

“We took a break for about two weeks. Before that it had been almost every day. I sent [parts of episode three] to Liam’s parents and Cheryl to see, for obvious reasons, and I said, ‘Look, I don’t want you to just see it when it airs’.

“And so the production company sent it to them, and they were fine with it. It was respectful, I think.”

The show also sees Cowell team up with Brit Award-winning singer-songwriter Kamille, who helps her former mentor Simon find a new boyband. She commented on Simon’s decision to continue filming the series in a Q&A with The Mirror.

She explained: “Not so much, at the time he took a break from filming because it was so devastating and he needed time to process it. We were all there for each other but it was such a sad time, I think part of you’s still shaken by it. But you know what, Simon’s very strong – and he really didn’t want to let these boys down, I think he carried on for that reason.”

The official synopsis reads: “Music mogul and record executive Simon Cowell has single-handedly created some of the biggest music superstars in the world. In this brand-new Netflix docu-series, cameras follow him everywhere as he sets out to do it again, to try and create the next global boyband sensation.

Article continues below

“This is unlike any show he has made before. From raw open casting calls to the release of their debut single, this is an all-access pass for viewers to catch every moment of Simon’s next chapter. Will he strike gold once again?”

Brown University reports two dead, eight injured in US school shooting

Mayor Brett Smiley of Providence, Rhode Island, has confirmed that two people have been killed and eight more are critically injured after an active shooter was reported on the campus of Brown University.

Exams were under way on Saturday when the shooting began on the Ivy League campus in the United States.

Recommended Stories

list of 3 itemsend of list

The suspect remains at large, according to Rhode Island officials. They described the suspect as a man dressed in black who left the scene on foot, and they added that no weapons had been recovered.

At a news conference afterwards, Smiley said that university leaders became aware of the shooting at about 4:05pm local time (21:05 GMT), when a 911 call was received by emergency responders.

“I can confirm that there are two individuals who have died this afternoon, and there are another eight in critical status, though stable, at Rhode Island Hospital,” Smiley said.

“Those are the only injuries or casualties that we know at this time,” he added. “ But as I mentioned – and it’s important to remind folks – these numbers may change. We are still in the early hours.”

Smiley declined to identify the shooting victims, emphasising that the investigation was ongoing.

At approximately 4:22pm local time (21:22 GMT) on Saturday, the university issued an emergency update that there was a gunman near the Barus and Holley engineering and physics building.

“Lock doors, silence phones and stay hidden until further notice,” the university said in its update.

“Remember: RUN, if you are in the affected location, evacuate safely if you can; HIDE, if evacuation is not possible, take cover; FIGHT, as a last resort, take action to protect yourself.”

Upon arriving at the scene, law enforcement swept the building, according to Providence police chief Timothy O’Hara.

“They did a systematic search of the building. However, no suspect was located at that time,” O’Hara said. “They were able to clear that building and provide a safe place for all of the students and faculty and workers that were in that building to meet at.”

He added that it is not clear yet how the suspect entered the building but that he exited onto Hope Street.

At 5:27pm local time (22:27 GMT), Brown University reported that shots had been fired near Governor Street, approximately two blocks away from the engineering and physics lab.

In the lead-up to the news conference, it was unclear if law enforcement had detained a suspect, as conflicting reports circulated online.

The university, for instance, had to withdraw an early announcement that a suspect had been apprehended, writing, “Police do not have a suspect in custody and continue to search for suspect(s).”

US President Donald Trump published a similar retraction on his online platform, Truth Social, after erroneously posting at about 5:44pm (22:44 GMT) that the suspect was in custody.

“I have been briefed on the shooting that took place at Brown University in Rhode Island,” Trump also wrote. “The FBI is on the scene.”

Law enforcement remains on site at the university. The incident is currently under investigation.

Saturday’s shooting is the second major incident of gun violence on a university campus this week.

Just four days ago, on December 9, Kentucky State University in the southern city of Frankfort also experienced gunfire on campus, killing one student and leaving a second critically injured. The suspect in that case was identified as Jacob Lee Bard, the parent of a student at the school.

The risk of gun violence has transformed the academic experience in the US, with many schools holding preparedness drills for active shooter situations.

“This is just the reality of life in America. From first graders to middle schoolers to high schoolers to students in college, they do active shooting drills. So they know how to do this,” Al Jazeera correspondent Patty Culhane said from Maryland.

“What they tell them is: Avoid. Deny. Defend,” she added, citing a popular school safety slogan.

“Avoid” stands for staying away from danger. “Deny” is meant as advice if escape is not possible: Victims are advised to find shelter, stay out of sight, and use materials to create barricades, if necessary.

“Defend” is the final step: If avoiding or denying the danger is not possible, the motto advises those in a violent situation to use whatever they can to defend themselves from harm.

Mass shootings are a relatively common threat in the US.

The Gun Violence Archive, a nonprofit that tracks shootings in the US, has documented at least 389 mass shootings this year alone. It defines mass shootings as incidents where four or more people are shot or killed, not including the perpetrator.

Schools are often a target. The nonprofit Everytown for Gun Safety reports that there have been 154 incidents of gunfire on school campuses in 2025. Those incidents resulted in 49 deaths and 135 injuries.

Saturday’s shooting comes as the academic semester winds down at Brown University. The last day of classes for the fall semester was on Thursday, and the school is in its final examination period until December 20.

At the news conference, school officials said that exams had been under way on Saturday between 2pm and 5pm (19:00 GMT and 22:00 GMT).

The seventh-oldest university in the US, Brown is considered part of the prestigious Ivy League, a cluster of private research colleges in the Northeast. Its student body numbers 11,005, according to its website.

Mayor Smiley encouraged community members to reach out to one another as the city grapples with the aftermath of Saturday’s deadly shooting.

“ It’s going to be a difficult rest of the day, difficult weeks and months ahead as this community heals,” he said. “Each and every one of us can play a small role in that, in supporting one’s neighbour.”

Governor Dan McKee, meanwhile, explained that he had been in touch with the White House, as well as other governors whose states had experienced similar shootings in recent years.

“ The unthinkable has happened,” McKee said. “ Our thoughts go out to those who have been impacted by this in any way, and we’ll continue to provide assistance to the authorities here in Providence as well as statewide.”

Trump also encouraged people to pray for the Brown community.

“I’ve been fully briefed on the Brown University situation. What a terrible thing it is,” the president said as he arrived at the White House on Saturday night. “All we can do right now is pray for the victims and for those that were very badly hurt, it looks like.”

Lim, 71, becomes oldest winner at World Championship

Getty Images

Paul Lim became the oldest player to win a match at the PDC World Championship as the 71-year-old claimed a stunning victory over Jeffrey de Graaf.

Backed by a partisan crowd at the Alexandra Palace, the Singapore veteran claimed a 3-1 success over the Dutch-born Swede.

He beat a record held by Northern Irishman John MaGowan, who was 67 when he knocked out Chris Mason in the first round of the tournament in December 2008.

“A moment like this has kept me going for all these years,” said Lim.

“The standard of play nowadays is not like how it was before. This tournament is the Super Bowl of darts so I would say this is a good moment.”

Lim will face Luke Humphries in the second round after the 2024 world champion progressed with a 3-1 win over Ted Evetts in his opening match later on Saturday evening.

Humphries had cruised into a 2-0 lead against his fellow Englishman before Evetts pinched a set back.

However, 30-year-old Humphries regained his intensity and clinically finished out the contest with an average of 98.58, throwing eight 180s.

Lim, who thew the first world championship nine-darter at the BDO event at Lakeside in 1990, beat Humphries when the pair last met at the Ally Pally five years ago.

On meeting again, Humphries told Sky Sports: “He’s amazing, he’s a legend. The crowd are going to be against me so it’s going to be a tough game.”

Lim said: “I hope on a given day it can happen again. I never give up. He is good but he can be beaten.”

The crowd roared on Lim, who is 72 next month, when he won the first set against De Graaf befofe his opponent levelled the match.

Lim went ahead again after a scrappy third set as De Graaf wilted while the experienced ‘Singapore Slinger’ held his nerve in a tense fourth, sealing victory with an average of 86.52.

Five-time world championship semi-finalist Wayne Mardle said Lim was able to “take his chances” against De Graaf to secure an “incredible” win.

“If you have the desire, the passion but most of all the ability humans can achieve amazing things – and that was amazing,” said Mardle on Sky.

De Graaf was six years old when Lim made his PDC debut 29 years ago.

    • 51 minutes ago
    • 46 minutes ago
    • 1 day ago

Anderson survives scare

Gary Anderson celebratesGetty Images

In the afternoon session, Gary Anderson booked his place in the second round with a hard-fought 3-2 win over Adam Hunt.

Two-time champion Anderson, 54, was given a stern examination by world number 84 Hunt but the Flying Scotsman was able to battle back from 2-1 down to progress.

Anderson, seeded 14th, will next play the winner of the match between Connor Scutt and Simon Whitlock .

“That’s probably the best Adam has played all season. The first game is the hardest, but I’m through,” Anderson told Sky Sports.

Anderson, who won back-to-back world titles in 2015 and 2016, held his nerve to win the first set 3-2 against the 32-year-old Englishman.

However, he missed double top in the deciding leg in the second set and Hunt took his chance to level the match up with a confident 72 checkout.

Hunt won the third set as Anderson’s average plummeted but the Scot raised his game in the fourth and took control early in the decider as Hunt failed to recover from an early break of throw.

Elsewhere, Welsh amateur David Davies secured a dream tie with defending champion Luke Littler in the next round after causing a minor upset on his World Championship debut.

Davies claimed a 3-0 win over Belgium’s Mario Vandenbogaerde – 66th in the PDC rankings – thanks to a checkout average of 37.5%.

Andrew Gilding saw off a spirited effort from 22-year-old tournament debutant Cam Crabtree as he progressed with a 3-1 win over his fellow Englishman thanks to an average of 97.89.

Saturday’s results

Afternoon session

Mario Vandenbogaerde 0-3 David Davies

Andrew Gilding 3-1 Cam Crabtree

Luke Woodhouse (25) 3-1 Boris Krcmar

Gary Anderson (14) 3-2 Adam Hunt

Evening session

Jeffrey de Graaf 1-3 Paul Lim

Wessel Nijman (31) 3-0 Karel Sedlacek

Luke Humphries (2) 3-1 Ted Evetts

Sunday’s schedule

Afternoon session (12:30 GMT)

Ritchie Edhouse (27) v Jonny Tata

Dom Taylor v Oskar Lukasiak

Richard Veenstra v Nitin Kumar

Joe Cullen (32) v Bradley Brooks

Evening session (19:00)

Lukas Wenig v Wesley Plaisier

Dimitri van den Bergh (23) v Darren Beveridge

Stephen Bunting (4) v Sebastian Bialecki

Related topics

  • Darts

Liverpool icon Rush recovering in hospital from flu

Getty Images

Liverpool’s all-time leading goalscorer Ian Rush is recovering in hospital after spending two days in intensive care with flu.

Rush, 64, was taken into the Countess of Chester hospital last week with breathing difficulties.

A Liverpool spokesperson thanked staff at the hospital for “providing the best care possible” and said “everyone at Liverpool wishes him a speedy recovery”.

Rush spent two hugely successful spells at Liverpool either side of a stint at Juventus in the 1980s.

He scored a club-record 346 goals in 660 appearances for Liverpool, winning five First Division titles and two European Cups.

The striker, who also played for Leeds, Newcastle and Wrexham over a 22-year career, won 73 caps for Wales and was their leading scorer with 28 goals until that record was broken by Gareth Bale in 2018.

After hanging up his boots in 2000, Rush moved into management and had an eight-month spell in charge of Chester.

He currently works as an ambassador for Liverpool and regularly attends matches at Anfield.

Flu cases are soaring across the UK. An average of 2,660 patients per day were in hospital with flu in England last week – the highest for this time of year since records began in 2021, and up 55% on the week before, NHS England said.

Related topics

  • Liverpool
  • Football

More on this story

  • Anfield
  • Ask Me Anything logo