Judge rules Trump lawyer Alina Habba is unlawfully serving as US attorney

A federal judge has ruled that lawyer Alina Habba was unlawfully appointed to the role of acting United States attorney for the District of New Jersey

Thursday’s decision from District Judge Matthew Brann was a rebuke to the administration of President Donald Trump, who has sought to keep Habba, his former personal lawyer, in the role despite a previous court decision replacing her.

“Faced with the question of whether Ms Habba is lawfully performing the functions and duties of the office of the United States Attorney for the District of New Jersey, I conclude that she is not,” Brann wrote.

Brann accused the Trump administration of using “a novel series of legal and personnel moves” to keep Habba in her role as US attorney.

But, given the fact that Habba has not been officially confirmed to the position by the US Senate, Brann decided that her actions since July 1 “may be declared void”.

Brann, however, put his decision on hold pending a likely appeal from the Trump administration.

The challenge against Habba’s continued role as US attorney came from defendants in cases she was pursuing.

Two, Julien Giraud Jr and Julien Giraud III, were charged with drug and firearm-related offences. A third, Cesar Humberto Pina, was accused of laundering drug proceeds and participating in a “multi-million-dollar Ponzi-like investment fraud scheme”.

Lawyers for Pina released a statement praising the judge’s decision later on Thursday and calling for the Trump administration to follow federal procedure for appointing US attorneys.

“Prosecutors wield enormous power, and with that comes the responsibility to ensure they are qualified and properly appointed,” lawyers Abbe David Lowell and Gerald Krovatin wrote in the statement.

“We appreciate the thoroughness of the court’s opinion, and its decision underscores that this Administration cannot circumvent the congressionally mandated process for confirming US Attorney appointments.”

Trump clashes with judicial branch

Thursday’s court decision is likely to continue the power clash between President Trump and the judiciary, whom he has accused of being politically biased against him and his allies.

While Habba awaits a confirmation hearing before the US Senate, she has served in the US attorney position on an interim basis.

But such interim appointments are capped at a period of 120 days. Continuing beyond that time span requires approval from a panel of judges in the district.

The panel, however, declined Habba’s bid to stay in the role on July 22. It named her second-in-command, career prosecutor Desiree Grace, to replace her as US attorney.

But the Trump administration swiftly moved to reject the judges’ decision. Attorney General Pam Bondi fired Grace and said Habba would continue in her role regardless of the July 22 court order.

“This Department of Justice does not tolerate rogue judges,” Bondi wrote on social media.

The Justice Department, under Trump, has sought to retain term-capped interim US attorneys elsewhere as well.

But Habba’s handling of her position has drawn particular scrutiny, as has her close relationship with the president.

Habba was an early appointment to Trump’s second term. In December, just weeks after winning the 2024 presidential election, Trump revealed he would bring her into the White House as a counsellor for his administration.

Then, on March 24, he announced she would be his pick for US attorney for the New Jersey district.

Previously, Habba has represented Trump as a personal lawyer in several civil cases.

While she won one defamation suit brought against Trump by former reality TV contestant Summer Zervos, she lost two high-profile cases: a defamation suit brought by writer E Jean Carroll and a civil fraud case led by New York Attorney General Letitia James. Trump is currently appealing both of those decisions.

Questions surrounding Habba’s leadership

Since taking on the role of interim US attorney, Habba told a podcaster that she hoped to help “turn New Jersey red” – an indication she may use her traditionally nonpartisan position for partisan aims.

She has also led probes and prosecutions that critics denounced as politically motivated. In one instance, she opened an investigation into New Jersey’s Democratic Governor Phil Murphy over his immigration policies.

In another, she charged Newark Mayor Ras Baraka for trespassing after he attempted to join several Congress members on a tour of the Delaney Hall immigration detention facility.

Those charges were later dropped, and a member of Habba’s office was rebuked in court. “An arrest, particularly of a public figure, is not a preliminary investigative tool,” Judge Andre Espinosa told the prosecutor.

Baraka has since filed a civil complaint accusing Habba of “subjecting him to false arrest and malicious prosecution”.

Polvara stars for Aberdeen in Europa League – but will he play more?

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.

At the start of the week, rumours were swirling that Aberdeen midfielder Dante Polvara was a transfer target for Hibernian. Fans on social media were aghast.

By late Thursday, the American was the hero against 10-man FCSB in the Europa League, coming off the bench to spark a comeback from 2-0 down as Aberdeen drew 2-2 in their play-off first leg.

The midfielder is a fans’ favourite at Pittodrie because of his warm personality, wholehearted displays and ability as a rounded midfielder.

Manager Jimmy Thelin has used him sparingly so far this season, Polvara appearing for a combined 45 minutes as a substitute in Aberdeen’s three games before Thursday.

The American was introduced after 58 minutes against FCSB and played off the left, scoring a brilliant goal just three minutes later to revive Aberdeen’s hopes.

The 25-year-old’s performance helped cancel out the defensive mistakes which had undermined the Scottish Premiership side’s display for an hour.

Polvara’s ‘huge’ impact

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.

Scoring three minutes after coming on is a dream impact for any substitute, which is what the rangy Polvara did.

But it was not just the fact he scored but the quality of the goal itself which was so impressive. A cross was guided behind him by Adil Aouchiche, and he reacted brilliantly to get to the ball first.

His awareness and agility to swivel and hit it first time off his left foot was even better, with the ball kissing the inside of the post on its way in.

But Polvara did not stop there. Four minutes later, his pinpoint cross teed up Ester Sokler, whose header went narrowly wide.

At the death, Polvara’s sheer presence caused havoc in the box and, but for a good save, he might have won it for Aberdeen.

Overall, the American managed two shots, both on target, and created three chances, the joint most of any player.

According to Opta, he completed all 19 of his passes and won six of his eight duels, the joint most among Aberdeen players. He was everywhere.

“Polvara down that left-hand side was such an out ball,” Aberdeen legend Willie Miller said on BBC Scotland.

“He’s a big strong unit. And the goal – he shouldn’t be scoring from that position. Facing away from goal and he’s able to manoeuvre himself to strike it.

“That fired the crowd up and gave them the hope and optimism they could get something out of it.

What information do we collect from this quiz?

Will Polvara start the second leg?

That is the key question. Polvara’s time at Aberdeen has been constantly disrupted.

He was sent on loan to Charleston in his homeland a year after signing in 2022, and only on his return did then manager Barry Robson give him a chance.

Polvara repaid the faith in the 2023-24 season, scoring against both Eintracht Frankfurt and PAOK in the Conference League as he started to become more of a pivotal figure.

A hamstring tear last summer completely derailed his season as Thelin took charge, but even then he returned to make enough of an impact to help the team win the Scottish Cup.

He has been deployed as a centre-back, central midfielder and a winger in his time at Pittodrie – versatility which managers love but which often makes it difficult to nail down a particular spot.

With Thelin using a 4-2-3-1 system and preferring Sivert Heltne Nilsen and Ante Palaversa in the deeper roles and Aouchiche as the number 10 – along with traditional quick wingers out wide – Polvara starting would mean a change of tack from the Aberdeen boss.

Such was his impact on Thursday, though, Thelin may just be considering it, particularly as Polvara showed he appears to be over his fitness issues.

After those Hibs rumours surfaced, there were reports Polvara is set to be offered a new contract by Aberdeen, with his current deal up at the end of the season.

Get in touch

Related topics

  • Aberdeen
  • Scottish Football
  • Football

Billy Connolly reveals pal Elton John inspired his latest venture as he reveals new work

Comedian Sir Billy Connolly, who was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease in 2013, has released new artwork which is inspired by Sir Elton John

Billy Connolly speaks about Elton John’s inspiration as he releases new artwork(Image: Alan Davidson/Shutterstock)

Billy Connolly has revealed how his time touring with Sir Elton John in the 1970s has inspired his latest venture. The comedian, 82, has released a string of new limited edition art works under the series, Born On A Rainy Day, in which he recalls some of the fondest memories from his life.

Billy, who was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease in 2013, revealed his pal Sir Elton John inspired one of the pieces, named Saturday Night, which shows a piano player in action, with Sir Billy saying the character in his piece “does that leg thing which is pure Elton”.

Speaking about opening for the Rocket Man singer in 1976, he added: “It was that point of the show where he backheeled the stool and it tumbled off the stage. The roadies all dived so that it didn’t break. I saw Elton lately and he was better than I’ve ever seen him. He’s an amazing performer”.

READ MORE: Princess Andre’s TV debut hit with ‘tricky’ issue amid Peter and Katie feudREAD MORE: Katie Price’s cryptic response to Peter Andre statement in full as she calls herself a ‘sinner’

The Ivor Novello Awards at Gorsvenor House, London. Pictured, Billy Connolly and Elton John. 7th April 1986.
Billy Connolly and Elton John together in 1986(Image: Mirrorpix)

Sir Billy, who began drawing in 2007 and has built a name for himself as an artist since his retirement from comedy in 2018, has also released Sausage Tree, which reflects on his childhood, Sunburned, which depicts a sunburned Scottish man, and Fly Away Peter, which shows a multicoloured figure surrounded by birds.

The Glasgow-born star added: “It’s taken me years to call my art beautiful, I would never dream of saying it before for the chance that somebody would say, ‘ it’s crap, you’re no good’, but I’m quite good. I can make people smile and feel happy. It’s great”.

Sir Billy was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease in 2013 and has been candid about his health in recent years. Last year the comedian said he was ‘ not dead or broken ‘ in his book, The Accidental Artist.

He wrote: “The Parkinson’s just rumbles along, doing its thing. It bothered me for a while but when I think about it I suppose I’m lucky I didn’t get something worse because I was a welder”.

The comedian previously worked as a welder in shipyards in Glasgow in the 1960sbefore persuing his comedy career. He wrote, “The diseases that they talk about now are ones that weren’t discovered when I was working in the shipyards.”

“They were unaware of the risks associated with asbestos. Additionally, accidents frequently left men dead. I also had an accident. My ankle was broken when I fell 40 feet into three feet of water after leaving the ship in the Clyde.

Sir Billy earlier this month issued a warning to fans about fake accounts of him on social media, telling them that he and his wife, Pamela Stephenson, had been duped by artificial intelligence.

He claimed there was “criminal intent” and that scammers had been “impersonating me, frequently reaching out to fans and soliciting direct messaging.”

Continue reading the article.

Sir Billy has continued to record TV programmes since his retirement, with his most recent projects including shows such as 2018’s Billy Connolly: Made In Scotland, Billy Connolly’s Great American Trail in 2019, and Billy Connolly Does…, which began airing in 2022.

Beginning at 8am on Friday, Castle Fine Art will start selling the new pieces.

Billy Connolly reveals pal Elton John inspired his latest venture as he reveals new work

Comedian Sir Billy Connolly, who was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease in 2013, has released new artwork which is inspired by Sir Elton John

Billy Connolly speaks about Elton John’s inspiration as he releases new artwork(Image: Alan Davidson/Shutterstock)

Billy Connolly has revealed how his time touring with Sir Elton John in the 1970s has inspired his latest venture. The comedian, 82, has released a string of new limited edition art works under the series, Born On A Rainy Day, in which he recalls some of the fondest memories from his life.

Billy, who was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease in 2013, revealed his pal Sir Elton John inspired one of the pieces, named Saturday Night, which shows a piano player in action, with Sir Billy saying the character in his piece “does that leg thing which is pure Elton”.

Speaking about opening for the Rocket Man singer in 1976, he added: “It was that point of the show where he backheeled the stool and it tumbled off the stage. The roadies all dived so that it didn’t break. I saw Elton lately and he was better than I’ve ever seen him. He’s an amazing performer.”

READ MORE: Princess Andre’s TV debut hit with ‘tricky’ issue amid Peter and Katie feudREAD MORE: Katie Price’s cryptic response to Peter Andre statement in full as she calls herself a ‘sinner’

The Ivor Novello Awards at Gorsvenor House, London. Pictured, Billy Connolly and Elton John. 7th April 1986.
Billy Connolly and Elton John together in 1986(Image: Mirrorpix)

Sir Billy, who began drawing in 2007 and has built a name for himself as an artist since his retirement from comedy in 2018, has also released Sausage Tree, which reflects on his childhood, Sunburned, which depicts a sunburned Scottish man, and Fly Away Peter, which shows a multicoloured figure surrounded by birds.

The Glasgow-born star added: “It’s taken me years to call my art beautiful, I would never dream of saying it before for the chance that somebody would say, ‘it’s crap, you’re no good’, but I’m quite good. I can make people smile and feel happy. It’s great.”

Sir Billy was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease in 2013 and has been candid about his health in recent years. Last year the comedian said he was ‘not dead or broken’ in his book, The Accidental Artist.

He wrote: “The Parkinson’s just rumbles along, doing its thing. It bothered me for a while but when I think about it I suppose I’m lucky I didn’t get something worse because I was a welder.”

The comedian previously worked as a welder in shipyards in Glasgow in the 1960sbefore persuing his comedy career. He penned: “The diseases they talk about now due to welding weren’t known about when I was in the shipyards,” he said.

“They didn’t know about the hazards of asbestos. And men were always dying in accidents too. I was in an accident myself. I fell off the ship into the Clyde, dropped 40 feet into three feet of water and broke my ankle.”

Earlier this month, Sir Billy warned fans about scammers impersonating him online, telling them he and his wife, Pamela Stephenson, had been impersonated using artificial intelligence.

He said scammers had been “impersonating me, often reaching out to fans soliciting direct messaging”, adding there “could well be criminal intent”.

Article continues below

Sir Billy has continued to record TV programmes since his retirement, with his most recent projects including shows such as 2018’s Billy Connolly: Made In Scotland, Billy Connolly’s Great American Trail in 2019, and Billy Connolly Does…, which began airing in 2022.

The new pieces are available from Castle Fine Art from 8am on Friday.

Sir Tom Jones stops Cardiff gig as he addresses boos from crowd

Tom Jones was on stage at Cardiff Castle when he spoke out about the controversy surrounding one of his biggest hits that was banned from use in Welsh rugby matches

Sir Tom Jones was booed as he addressed the controversy surrounding one of his signature songs on Wednesday night(Image: John Myers)

Sir Tom Jones was booed as he addressed the controversy surrounding one of his signature songs on Wednesday night. The singer, 85, headlined the Cardiff Castle for two nights from 20 August, and worked his way through classics like What’s New Pussycat, I’m Growing Old and Sex Bomb for the crowd.

But things became heated when it came to Delilah, which was adopted as the Welsh rugby national anthem for many years until it was banned by the Welsh Rugby Union in 2023. The banning came as a result of the song’s lyrical content, which describe a man murdering the titular Delilah after he discovers she has been unfaithful.

One line reads: “I crossed the street to her house and she opened the door; she stood there laughing, I felt the knife in my hand and she laughed no more”, and it was decided three years ago that the song should not be heard at major sporting events in Wales anymore as was thought to glorify violence against women.

READ MORE: Sir Tom Jones’ comeback show leaves audience in tears as he makes epic stage returnREAD MORE: Sir Tom Jones, 85, cancels gig hours before he’s due on stage with sad health update

Sie Tom Jones
The Voice UK judge used to look forward to hearing his track performed by thousands ahead of a big game, and insisted that none of the lyrics should be ‘taken literally(Image: John Myers)

Speaking out about the banning, Tom told the crowds at his recent gig: “Who’s that man who said we shouldn’t sing that song anymore? That used to make my day that on an international match.”

The Voice UK judge used to look forward to hearing his track performed by thousands ahead of a big game, and insisted that none of the lyrics should be ‘taken literally’.

He added: “I used to wait for it and then they said we can’t sing it anymore. Who is this man who said we can’t sing Delilah? They said it’s about a man killing his wife with a knife. Well it is, but you shouldn’t take it literally.” It was then that crowd booed in support of Tom’s backing of the song, reports WalesOnline.

Delilah was first released in 1968 and became the sixth-best-selling single of that year after it reached number two. It went on to become one of Tom’s signature hits. It featured in the 1990 film Edward Scissorhands that starred Johnny Depp and Winona Ryder, and the crooner performed it at Queen Elizabeth’s Diamond Jubilee in 2012.

But questions about the violent nature began to rise as far back as 2015, with the song’s official removal from the Principality Stadium taking place nearly a decade later.

A Principality Stadium spokesperson said: “Delilah will not feature on the playlist for choirs for rugby internationals at Principality Stadium. The WRU removed the song from its half-time entertainment and music playlist during international matches in 2015. Guest choirs have also more recently been requested not to feature the song during their pre-match performances and throughout games.

“The WRU condemns domestic violence of any kind. We have previously sought advice from subject matter experts on the issue of censoring the song and we are respectfully aware that it is problematic and upsetting to some supporters because of its subject matter.”

The use of the song had previously been criticised by Dafydd Iwan, whose version of Yma O Hyd has become synonymous with welsh football, after he said it was “a song about murder and it does tend to trivialise the idea of murdering a woman.” Rhondda MP Chris Bryant referenced the rise in domestic abuse during live sport as reason to stop playing it.

Article continues below

Sir Tom Jones stops Cardiff gig as he addresses boos from crowd

Tom Jones was on stage at Cardiff Castle when he spoke out about the controversy surrounding one of his biggest hits that was banned from use in Welsh rugby matches

Sir Tom Jones was booed as he addressed the controversy surrounding one of his signature songs on Wednesday night(Image: John Myers)

Sir Tom Jones was booed as he addressed the controversy surrounding one of his signature songs on Wednesday night. The singer, 85, headlined the Cardiff Castle for two nights from 20 August, and worked his way through classics like What’s New Pussycat, I’m Growing Old and Sex Bomb for the crowd.

But things became heated when it came to Delilah, which was adopted as the Welsh rugby national anthem for many years until it was banned by the Welsh Rugby Union in 2023. The banning came as a result of the song’s lyrical content, which describe a man murdering the titular Delilah after he discovers she has been unfaithful.

One line reads: “I crossed the street to her house and she opened the door; she stood there laughing, I felt the knife in my hand and she laughed no more”, and it was decided three years ago that the song should not be heard at major sporting events in Wales anymore as was thought to glorify violence against women.

READ MORE: Sir Tom Jones’ comeback show leaves audience in tears as he makes epic stage returnREAD MORE: Sir Tom Jones, 85, cancels gig hours before he’s due on stage with sad health update

Sie Tom Jones
The Voice UK judge used to look forward to hearing his track performed by thousands ahead of a big game, and insisted that none of the lyrics should be ‘taken literally(Image: John Myers)

Speaking out about the banning, Tom told the crowds at his recent gig: “Who’s that man who said we shouldn’t sing that song anymore? That used to make my day that on an international match.”

The Voice UK judge used to look forward to hearing his track performed by thousands ahead of a big game, and insisted that none of the lyrics should be ‘taken literally’.

He added: “I used to wait for it and then they said we can’t sing it anymore. Who is this man who said we can’t sing Delilah? They said it’s about a man killing his wife with a knife. Well it is, but you shouldn’t take it literally.” It was then that crowd booed in support of Tom’s backing of the song, reports WalesOnline.

Delilah was first released in 1968 and became the sixth-best-selling single of that year after it reached number two. It went on to become one of Tom’s signature hits. It featured in the 1990 film Edward Scissorhands that starred Johnny Depp and Winona Ryder, and the crooner performed it at Queen Elizabeth’s Diamond Jubilee in 2012.

But questions about the violent nature began to rise as far back as 2015, with the song’s official removal from the Principality Stadium taking place nearly a decade later.

A Principality Stadium spokesperson said: “Delilah will not feature on the playlist for choirs for rugby internationals at Principality Stadium. The WRU removed the song from its half-time entertainment and music playlist during international matches in 2015. Guest choirs have also more recently been requested not to feature the song during their pre-match performances and throughout games.

“The WRU condemns domestic violence of any kind. We have previously sought advice from subject matter experts on the issue of censoring the song and we are respectfully aware that it is problematic and upsetting to some supporters because of its subject matter.”

The use of the song had previously been criticised by Dafydd Iwan, whose version of Yma O Hyd has become synonymous with welsh football, after he said it was “a song about murder and it does tend to trivialise the idea of murdering a woman.” Rhondda MP Chris Bryant referenced the rise in domestic abuse during live sport as reason to stop playing it.

Article continues below