The Israeli military has “without a doubt” committed war crimes in the Palestinian territory, according to Matthew Miller, a former US State Department spokesperson who spent months defending Israel’s actions during the Gaza war.
Miller, however, stated on Monday that he did not believe that there was a genocide in Gaza.
“I don’t believe it’s a genocide, but I do believe that Israel has committed war crimes,” Miller said.
The ex-spokesperson was one of former president Joe Biden’s prominent supporters of Israel, which killed tens of thousands of Palestinians and flattened a large portion of the region.
Israel is accused of committing genocidal crimes, an act that is intended to completely or partially annihilate the Palestinian people, by leading rights organizations and experts from the UN.
No restrictions on US citizens
Miller’s remarks raise questions about why the Biden administration remained militarized in Israel despite US laws that forbid military aid to nations that violate international law and human rights.
Despite the overwhelming evidence supporting Israeli abuses, the former US president’s advisers repeatedly said they were unable to conclude that Israel was violating the law of war or restricting humanitarian aid to Palestinians.
At least 54, 381 Palestinians have died and 124, 054 have been injured, according to Gaza’s health ministry. 2.2.3 million people have been forced to flee the enclave, and a blockade by Israel is a source of famine risk.
Miller frequently clashed with journalists who were questioning the US’s handling of Gaza, including bombings of hospitals and camps for Palestinian civilians, while working for the State Department.
Miller was mocked for laughing during a question about Israel’s blocking of aid to Gaza in one incident in November. State-sponsored humanitarian aid in conflict zones is specifically prohibited by US law.
When asked about specific atrocities, such as the 2012 killing of six-year-old Palestinian girl Hind Rajab, Miller frequently claimed that US officials discussed the incident with their Israeli counterparts, who are now looking into it.
The spokesperson would then continue to use these alleged contacts and investigations, sometimes months after the incident, to dismiss inquiries about alleged Israeli war crimes.
expressing official opinion
Miller made an appearance on the Sky News podcast criticizing his own method of responding to questions while serving as a spokesperson. Israel has opened inquiries, we are aware of. However, look, those investigations are still taking a long time. And he claimed that no Israeli soldiers are being held accountable.
Miller emphasized in the interview on Monday that Miller was speaking for Biden’s administration’s official position rather than his own opinion.
You support the administration’s policies, he said, and you represent both the president and the administration. You can also express your own opinions when you’re not in charge of the administration.
When asked about his experience with the problem, Miller claimed that there were “small and big” disagreements between the Biden administration and how to deal with Israel.
“Throughout the course of the process, there were disagreements about how to handle policy.” He claimed that some of those disagreements were significant and others were minor.
He made a particular mention of the tensions between Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Biden.
He acknowledged that “there probably was” more that the US could have done to pressure Israel into halting the conflict and halting the killing of “thousands of innocent civilians who didn’t want this war.”
Hamas aims to take actions.
Hamas, a Palestinian organization, claimed Miller’s remarks confirm Israel’s crimes and underscore Washington’s “direct responsibility as a true partner” in the genocide against Palestinians on Tuesday.
In a statement, Hamas asks the international community and international legal authorities to investigate these obscene confessions and bring legal action right away.
It was “outrageous” for Miller to wait until he was out of office to acknowledge that Israel had committed war crimes in Gaza, according to Raed Jarrar, the advocacy director at DAWN, a US-based advocacy organization.
“US officials who are aware of atrocities are occurring and continue to defend them from behind the podium are complicit, not neutral. Israel’s genocide was helped by Miller’s silence while in power. He has blood from Palestine on his hands, according to an email from Jarrar to Al Jazeera.