Slider1
Slider2
Slider3
Slider4
previous arrow
next arrow

Archive May 1, 2025

Man Utd Beat 10-Man Bilbao To Close In On Europa League Final

Bruno Fernandes struck twice as Manchester United put one foot in the Europa League final with a clinical away performance to beat 10-man Athletic Bilbao 3-0 on Thursday.

The fervent home fans were enraged when Athletic defender Daniel Vivian was sent off for pulling back Rasmus Hojlund and Fernandes slotted home the resulting penalty, after Casemiro had opened the scoring against the run of play in the semi-final first leg.

Fernandes rolled in a third before half-time as Ruben Amorim’s side moved a step closer to the final, to be held at Athletic’s San Mames stadium.

Athletic Bilbao’s Spanish forward #21 Maroan Sannadi (L) is challenged by Manchester United’s Brazilian midfielder #18 Casemiro during the UEFA Europa League semi final first leg football match between Athletic Club Bilbao and Manchester United at the San Mames stadium in Bilbao, on May 1, 2025. (Photo by ANDER GILLENEA / AFP)

The hosts have been dreaming of winning a first European trophy on their own soil but their hopes were demolished by United’s professional display in the north of Spain — and Athletic’s supporters argued, the refereeing.

READ ALSO: Chelsea On Brink Of Conference League Final After Thrashing Djurgarden

Languishing in 14th in the Premier League, Champions League qualification for United is only possible with a Europa League triumph, as is access to the £100 million ($133 million) honeypot it entails.

Despite regularly crumbling under pressure this season, the Red Devils — who produced a stunning comeback against Lyon in the quarter-finals — first survived and then thrived in a hostile environment.

Manchester United’s English defender #23 Luke Shaw (L) and Manchester United’s Dutch defender #04 Matthijs de Ligt react after the UEFA Europa League semi final first leg football match between Athletic Club Bilbao and Manchester United at the San Mames stadium in Bilbao, on May 1, 2025. (Photo by ANDER GILLENEA / AFP)

“We looked a little bit nervous at times in the first 20 minutes… we weathered the storm and we knew we’d get our chance,” Man United’s Harry Maguire told TNT Sports.

“It was a clinical first half, professional second half… It’s a great victory in the end but there’s another big game next week.”

With May 1 a bank holiday in Spain the streets of Bilbao were filled with red-and-white striped shirts from the morning onwards, in party mode.

Athletic Bilbao players react after the UEFA Europa League semi final first leg football match between Athletic Club Bilbao and Manchester United at the San Mames stadium in Bilbao, on May 1, 2025. (Photo by ANDER GILLENEA / AFP)

The San Mames was rocking as fans greeted their heroes, all of them born or raised in the Basque country, as per the club’s century-long policy.

Alejandro Garnacho’s early strike gave the hosts a scare but the forward was offside.

Beyond that the early stages of the match for United were about gritting their teeth and holding off the Basque side and their raucous supporters.

 Red card rocks hosts

Alex Berenguer forced a smart low save from Manchester United goalkeeper Andre Onana, and Inaki Williams headed narrowly over.

Victor Lindelof made a vital block to thwart Berenguer after Nico Williams fed his brother Inaki, who was given too much space on the right wing.

The hosts were ascendant and when former Real Madrid midfielder Casemiro opened the scoring for United it came as a shock.

Athletic Bilbao’s Spanish midfielder #23 Mikel Jauregizar Alboniga (L) challenges Manchester United’s Danish defender #13 Patrick Dorgu for the ball during the UEFA Europa League semi final first leg football match between Athletic Club Bilbao and Manchester United at the San Mames stadium in Bilbao, on May 1, 2025. (Photo by ANDER GILLENEA / AFP)

Just as much of a surprise was the way United created the goal, with centre-back Maguire dribbling down the right flank as Mikel Jaureguizar floundered in his wake.

The defender fizzed a cross into the area, which Manuel Ugarte flicked on to the back post for Casemiro to nod home from close range.

It seemed like a smash-and-grab but soon United had a second, when Vivian was penalised for pulling back Hojlund as he tried to connect with a cross.

The defender was sent off to add insult to injury, as Athletic fans howled in anger, and Fernandes rolled home from the spot.

Athletic coach Ernesto Valverde made a double substitution, trying to stem the bleeding, but his team shipped a third before half-time.

Ugarte’s clever backheel played Fernandes through on goal and he stroked home with ease.

Noussair Mazraoui crashed a shot off the crossbar from distance as United almost grabbed a fourth before the break.

Norwegian referee Espen Eskas and his colleagues were barracked by the home fans, seeing their aspirations to glory evaporate before their eyes.

They were further enraged, waving anything white to show their disgust, when Maroan Sannadi tumbled under pressure from Maguire as he ran towards goal but no foul was awarded.

United largely controlled the game in the second half but they could not add a fourth despite probing.

The second leg takes place next Thursday at Old Trafford, ahead of the final on May 21 against Tottenham or Bodo/Glimt.

“At the slightest contact (Hojlund) let himself fall and the bad luck is that the penalty was given,” said Inaki Williams.

“We weren’t particularly great, so we shouldn’t make excuses — we’re three goals down but we’re capable of mounting a comeback.”

Women Shouldn’t Be Shamed For Fertility Struggles – Chimamanda

Chimamanda Adichie, a well-known Nigerian author, has revealed details of her personal journey as a mother and why she chose to announce the birth of her twin boys via surrogacy in the media.

The 47-year-old author stated that she hoped that her candor would lessen the societal pressure that many women experience regarding fertility during her debut live broadcast of the #WithChude talk show on Sunday.

“I thought there were many women who would then face pressure from people who would say, “Look, Chimamanda is 47 and she has children at that age, what about you?” she stated.

The award-winning author, Ivara Esege, who is married to a medical doctor, called for the end of the stigma that surrounds women’s reproductive health and fertility issues.

“I just think it’s too much of a burden for women,” she said, “because there is so much shame around fertility issues.” I don’t believe in that kind of shame because “women are ashamed when they have fibroids, and women are ashamed when they have difficulties getting pregnant.”

Are Women Permitted to Have Their Own Dreams, Wonders Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie?

The author of “Half of a Yellow Sun” stated that her hope was that her candor would bring normalcy to conversations about unconventional paths to motherhood, despite her initial regrets for disclosing details about the birth of her children.

She said, “My boys are so precious to me.” And I detested the politicization of anything about them. So, on the one hand, I thought, “I wish I hadn’t talked about it,” but there’s no way I’m going to lie about how they were created.

If there is anything positive to be gained from this, I’m hoping that more women will be less repressed about discussing motherhood through unconventional means. I don’t believe anyone would benefit from our society’s judgmental attitude.

Adichie gave details about the birth of her twins earlier in February, but she chose to keep their identities a secret to prevent the media from seeing them.

She added that many Nigerians were unaware that she had married in 2019, and that she preferred to avoid the public’s view of her private life.

Adichie reiterated that she has no regrets about speaking out or the negative online reviews she received.

She said, “My daughter and my babies are the best gift I’ve ever received.” No regrets, then.

Sutton’s predictions v singer Sasha Keable

The Premier League’s bottom two meet at King Power Stadium on Saturday, so will Leicester or Southampton manage to pick up a rare victory?

“Saints still need a point to beat Robbie Savage’s useless Derby side, and avoid a share of the ‘worst Premier League team ever’ trophy,” said BBC Sport football expert Chris Sutton.

“But it says it all about how bad both teams have been this season that I still find it hard to back Leicester, even against them.

“The Foxes have not even scored at home in the league since 8 December, but if they can’t score there against Southampton then they might as well close the whole club down.”

Sutton is making predictions for all 380 Premier League games this season, against a variety of guests.

For week 35, he takes on British-Colombian singer-songwriter Sasha Keable, who supports Arsenal.

Sasha’s new single, Act Right, is out now. It has already racked up more than 1.4m views on TikTok.

Do you agree with their scores? You can make your own predictions below.

The most popular scoreline selected for each game is used in the scoreboards and tables at the bottom of this page.

Sasha KeableSasha Keable

Sasha is a singer now but grew up in the centre of the football world – her stepdad, Nick Broad, was head of sports science at Blackburn Rovers and Chelsea, and was working with Carlo Ancelotti as performance manager at Paris St-Germain when he died in a car accident in 2013.

“I’ve seen all sides of football, not just as a fan,” she told BBC Sport. “When Carlo got fired by Chelsea, my stepdad was fired too. He didn’t know what he was going to do, but then Carlo went to PSG and asked him to go with him.

“Sadly he passed away while he was in Paris but we are still close to the Ancelotti family. He and Carlo were such good friends.

“I look back now and my stepdad was a real pioneer in his work in sports science and nutrition. The things he introduced, like GPS tracking in training and collecting cardio data, were all new then but they are industry standard now.

“It’s incredible to see his work live on in that way. Some of his old friends and colleagues reach out to me now when they see me doing my own thing on social media and talk about how his work was incredible.

Nick Broad (right) celebrates with Carlo Ancelotti (centre) after Chelsea's FA Cup win in 2010, which completed a double of Premier League and FA Cup that seasonGetty Images

Before becoming a singer, Sasha dreamed of being a footballer herself. Now she settles for collecting shirts instead, with a Tino Asprilla Colombia shirt from 1994 taking pride of place.

“I played all the time when I was a kid, from the age of about six,” explained Sasha.

“It was a bit different for girls then because it was before the women’s game really took off and you didn’t really have a route to becoming a professional in this country. I wanted to go to the United States to play.

“I was quite a tomboy so I used to play with the boys all the time – I had to. We did not even have a girls team at my school until my friends and I asked to play with the boys and, after that, they formed a team for us.

“Fortunately it’s all changed now and football is so much more accessible for girls. If you don’t have the chance to try something, how do you know if you will love it?”

Premier League predictions

Friday, 2 May

What information do we collect from this quiz?

This should be a great game, because Wolves are so powerful and they will have no fear at all after winning six games in a row.

But Manchester City have looked much more solid in the past few weeks and they are on a bit of a roll themselves, with four successive wins in all competitions.

Pep Guardiola’s side will look to control this game, the same way they did in the first half of their FA Cup semi-final win over Nottingham Forest, but I don’t think they will find it easy to keep Wolves quiet.

Still, I went against City in their last home game, against Aston Villa, and I was wrong. I am not going to make the same mistake again.

Sutton’s prediction: 2-1

Saturday, 3 May

What information do we collect from this quiz?

It would be easy to say the wheels have come off at Aston Villa, wouldn’t it?

In the past couple of weeks, they have gone out of the Champions League and FA Cup, and losing their last Premier League game has left them playing catch-up in the top-five race.

I don’t think Unai Emery’s side will crumble from here, though, even if Marcus Rashford’s season-ending injury is a big blow.

Villa need to win this, and they also need a big performance from Ollie Watkins. If he starts banging the goals in again then that would be a huge boost for their run-in.

Fulham are a nightmare to predict, as I’ve mentioned in previous weeks, and they are certainly capable of getting something here.

I don’t think Villa can keep a clean sheet – which probably means they will stop Fulham scoring – but I have a feeling things will click for them in front of goal.

Also, they are at home too so, if they need them, their fans can help to get them over the line.

Sutton’s prediction: 3-1

What information do we collect from this quiz?

I am covering this game for BBC Radio 5 Live and I am really looking forward to going to Goodison Park again.

Everything points towards a home win, despite Everton losing their previous two games.

Ipswich are definitely down now and, while they won’t throw in the towel, they might be a little less spirited now they know they are relegated.

Their confidence has been sapped over the course of the season and, after watching them recently, I can’t back them to get anything here.

They were flimsy against Arsenal, then well beaten by Newcastle, and it would be a shock if they scored at all, let alone break my record for the fastest goal scored by an away player at Goodison.

Everton have stuttered in the past couple of weeks but I don’t think that is a bad thing for David Moyes.

He has over-achieved since taking charge in January, when the reality is that he has got the same group of players as his predecessor, Sean Dyche, and there needs to be a lot of work done on improving that squad in the summer.

Sutton’s prediction: 2-0

What information do we collect from this quiz?

Leicester have been rotten but, somehow, Southampton have been even worse.

It’s sad to see Jamie Vardy leaving the Foxes at the end of the season, but maybe this might be the send-off he deserves. I am going with him to score the winner.

These two teams actually served up a thriller at St Mary’s Stadium back in October, when Vardy got one of Leicester’s goals as they fought back from 2-0 down to win 3-2.

I am expecting the same outcome here, just with a lot less excitement. The readers will go for a draw, I am sure of it, but I am pretty confident about Leicester taking this one.

Sutton’s prediction: 1-0

What information do we collect from this quiz?

We know how dangerous Bournemouth are, because they beat Arsenal in October, and if Mikel Arteta rests players then this game becomes even harder for the Gunners.

It’s a tricky situation for Arteta, because he will want to head to Paris St-Germain for the second leg of their Champions League semi-final with a bit of momentum, but he has got to balance that with the risk of injury to his key players.

Bournemouth’s form has improved of late, and the circumstances mean they definitely have a decent chance of doing the double over Arsenal this season.

This all boils down to what the Arsenal team is, so it is difficult to make a call without knowing that, but they are at home and even if they are not at full strength then I can still see them getting a draw.

Sutton’s prediction: 1-1

Sunday, 4 May

What information do we collect from this quiz?

We know Manchester United are going to make changes here, because seeing out the second leg of their Europa League semi-final with Athletic Bilbao is their priority.

Ruben Amorim’s side nicked a point at the very end of their game at Bournemouth last weekend, which sparked mass celebrations, but I really don’t see them doing the same against Brentford – they won’t be getting the bunting out this time.

The Bees are such a dangerous team when they come forward and they will keep on attacking United. Bryan Mbeumo and Yoane Wissa should get plenty of chances and I can see them getting a goal or two between them.

Sutton’s prediction: 2-0

What information do we collect from this quiz?

Brighton got back to winning ways last weekend thanks to Carlos Baleba’s brilliant late strike against West Ham.

The Seagulls beat Newcastle at St James’ Park earlier in the season too, but that was before Eddie Howe’s side hit their stride, and it is a big ask for Brighton to repeat that result.

Newcastle were just relentless in their win over Ipswich and another three points here would be massive in their bid for a top-five finish – I don’t think they will get them, but we will see a few goals.

Sutton’s prediction: 2-2

What information do we collect from this quiz?

This is 17th versus 16th in the Premier League which tells you how bad both teams have been this season.

Everyone knows Tottenham’s focus will be on their Europa League semi-final second leg with Bodo/Glimt so I think West Ham boss Graham Potter needs a result here more than Ange Postecoglou.

Potter’s results have been poor since he took over from Julen Lopetegui in January and the Hammers fans have not had the upturn they wanted in the way their team play either.

Spurs can still be dangerous even when they are out of form but Ange is not going to pick his strongest team. That gives West Ham a better chance of getting the win they badly need, but I don’t see them doing it in style.

Sutton’s prediction: 2-1

What information do we collect from this quiz?

I would usually be asking which Chelsea side will turn up, but that applies to Liverpool too this week.

Arne Slot’s side could have been out all week celebrating their title win and we don’t know how that will affect them.

You often play at your best when you have been on the lash in a scenario like theirs. For example, some of my best games for Celtic came after nights out where we had won something and were allowed to have a couple of beers, but I don’t know what to expect here.

Chelsea have nicked a couple of results recently, to stay in the race for the top five, but their performances have not been too convincing and their fans still don’t seem to have taken to Enzo Maresca’s playing style.

This is not the test for them that it would be if Liverpool were trying to close out the title but I don’t think Slot is the type to let anyone take their foot off the gas. He will put out a strong team and even if they play with more freedom, I still think Liverpool will leave with the points.

Sutton’s prediction: 1-2

Monday, 5 May

What information do we collect from this quiz?

Crystal Palace will be on a high after booking their place in the FA Cup final, so this is another very tricky game for Nottingham Forest, who slipped up at home against Brentford on Thursday.

Nuno Espirito Santo’s side will have to be stubborn and resolute to get anything at Selhurst Park. They have shown that kind of character plenty of times already this season but they really need it now.

Looking at the race for the top five you feel like every team involved needs to win every game, but of course that is not going to happen, and I can see my boyhood team Forest dropping more points here. I just hope it doesn’t prove crucial for them.

Sutton’s prediction: 1-1

How did Sutton do last week?

Chris got five correct results with one exact score from the nine Premier League games he predicted in week 34, giving him a total of 80 points.

He beat his guest, golf hero Lee Westwood, who got four correct results with no exact scores, leaving him on 40 points and tied with the BBC readers, who also got five correct results with one exact score.

Westwood and the BBC readers were wrong about both FA Cup semi-finals, while Chris correctly picked City to beat Forest and wrongly thought Aston Villa would beat Crystal Palace. Those ties do not count towards the weekly totals.

The other game from week 34, Manchester City’s 2-1 win over Aston Villa, took place on 22 April and does not count towards the weekly result either.

Weekly wins, ties & total scores after week 34

WinsTiesPoints
Guests1042,610
Chris952,910
You862,670

Source: BBC

Weekly wins, ties & total scores after week 34. .  .

Guest leaderboard 2024-25

Points
Liam Fray150
Dave Fishwick, Adam F
& Emma-Jean Thackray130
Jordan Stephens120
Dan Haggis, James Smith110
Paige Cavell, Mychelle90
& Tigerblind
Chris Sutton *86
Clara Amfo, Coldplay,
Felix from Divorce, Brad Kella
& Dave McCabe80
You *79
Jamie Demetriou, Rory Kinnear,
Kellie Maloney, Jon McClure,
Dougie Payne, Anton Pearson
Sherelle & Paul Smith70
Peter Hooton, Nemzzz,
Finn Russell, James Ryan
& Yizzy60
Ife Ogunjobi50
Eats Everything, Ed Patrick,
Mylee from JJFC
Bradley Simpson & Lee Westwood40
Sunny Edwards, Femi Koleoso,
Stephen Bunting & Tate from JJFC30

* Average after 34 weeks

Source: BBC

Guest leaderboard 2024-25. .  * Average after 34 weeks.

Related topics

  • Premier League
  • Football

Jesy Nelson shares update from hospital room ahead of birth of twins

Little Mix star Jesy Nelson has updated her hospital staff with a message as she awaits the arrival of her twins following her emergency operation in March.

Jesy Nelson gave an update on her status while she was in the hospital awaiting her twins.

Jesy Nelson has provided fans with an update as she remains in hospital before the birth of her twins. The former Little Mix singer, 32, has been receiving constant medical care after having emergency surgery earlier this year. She has been supported by partner musician Zion Foster, 26, throughout her worrying time in hospital. Jesy was rushed in after it was discovered her twins were at risk of a condition called twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome.

If untreated, the condition can cause issues for the unborn twins – including growth problems, organ failure, and even death. Still hospital-bound, Jesy has been providing update to her concerned fans. Over the weekend, she was able to watch her boyfriend Zion run the London Marathon on TV as he ran to raise awareness about the condition.

 Jesy Nelson
She has been supported by her partner Zion(Image: Instagram/jesynelson)

Jesy has since updated her hospital room with additional updates as she adjusts. As she was treated to a beauty session, she continued to be inspired and upbeat.

When she revealed her eyelash extensions, the pop star showed up up upbeat and thankful for some pampering. She explained to the fans, “So the lovely @glashesbyhols came and did my lashes yesterday and I can honestly say I’m obsessed.”

I’ve never had brown lashes before, and she made a little different shape, which I absolutely adore. Don’t believe I’ll ever return to black right away”!

Continue reading the article.

Following surgery in March, the couple took to Instagram to share information. Jesy said: “Hi guys, so we just wanted to give you an update because we know it’s been a while.

We want to wish all the amazing and resilient mothers out there a happy Mother’s Day. Second, I’ve been recovering because we’re still being treated in the hospital.

“But we have some fantastic news. The operation was a success, which is just incredible, and the TTTS has cleared up. We have the most amazing doctors, and we are so, so fortunate.

My cervix is very, very short, so I can’t leave the hospital because my waters could break at any point and I’m still very, very early, in essence.

The pregnant singer is currently being held in hospital
The singer has been receiving medical attention since March.

Jesy continued, “Ok, I can’t leave the hospital until I’ve spent a certain amount of weeks.” Although we pray that the babies will stay in my belly each week, we are also very grateful that they are still here, that they are still developing, and that we are also very thankful.

Zion then said, “We’re in such a blessed, blessed situation that we’re even able to make this video and share this good news.”

Zion also told the Mirror that Jesy is “ticking off milestones every week” until they can become proud parents. Speaking ahead of running the London Marathon, he said: “They’re just giving us so much hope they’re going to come out healthy and spend the least time in the neonatal unit as possible.

“We’re so grateful because Jesy and the twins have come through so much. There were so many times in this pregnancy we didn’t think we’d get to where we are now.”

Continue reading the article.

Jesy and Zion announced her twin pregnancy in January to fans on social media. He added: “I do think we’ve come out of the storm a little bit. I mean, look, the truth is she’s still premature.

The reality is that they still need to stay in, they say. But where we’ve arrived, we’re just so appreciative. We simply keep ticking off day by day, hoping to let them go as long as possible.

READ MORE: ‘Charlotte Tilbury’s new double-ended lip liner makes my lips look like they have filler’

Ozzy Osbourne admits he will only manage a few songs in final Black Sabbath gig

In preparation for the July show, Ozzy Osbourne will play alongside Black Sabbath for the final time.

Ozzy Osbourne has promised fans that their last show will have a “sample” of hits.

Ozzy Osbourne has vowed to “do the best I can” as he prepares to play his final ever live show with Black Sabbath. The frontman and singer, 76, has been diagnosed with a form of Parkinson’s and has had other health issues for a number of years now which have prevented him going back out on tour. Instead Ozzy and Black Sabbath will headline their final gig on July 5th at Villa Park in Birmingham, as part of an event titled “Back To The Beginning”.

For the first time in 20 years, this show will bring together the original band members, including Bill Ward, Ozzy Osbourne, Tony Iommi, Geezer Butler, and Tony Ward. Ozzy said, “I’ll be there, and I’ll do the best I can,” when he discussed the possibility of getting back on stage. So I’ll just have to “turn up” now.

Ozzy Osbourne
One last time will Ozzy enter the stage.

He added that “we’re only playing a few songs each,” and that fans can expect more. Because it’s going to be… what’s the word, I don’t want people to think “we’re getting ripped off.” You’ll receive a few Ozzy and Sabbath songs each as a sample.

Additionally, bands from various heavy metal genres, such as Metallica, Slayer, and Pantera, will play at the concert.

However, Ozzy won’t be able to play a full set due to his poor health. He also has Parkinson’s, and he fell at home in 2019 to worsen injuries from a near-fatal quad bike accident in 2003, preventing him from advancing on his No More Tours 2 shows in Europe and the UK.

Continue reading the article.

Due to illness, the Covid pandemic, and logistical issues, the tour had previously been rescheduled several times.

Ozzy told the Guardian, “You wake up the next morning and discover that something else has gone wrong. You start to believe that this will never come to an end.

He continued, adding that his wife Sharon had the idea behind the reunion concert as “something to give me a reason to get up in the morning.”

Without Ward on the drums, the band played its “last” gig in Birmingham in 2017 with Osborne, guitarist Iommi, and bassist Butler.

However, Ozzy missed the Rock ‘N’Roll Hall of Fame inauguration in America last year because of his poor health.

Osbourne, Iommi, Butler, and Ward were escaping a factory-based life in Birmingham where Black Sabbath’s story began.

Their 1970 debut album, which went on to become the UK’s top 10, opened the door to a long line of chart-topping hits.

With more than 75 million albums sold worldwide, they eventually became one of the most well-known and influential metal bands ever.

Osbourne was added for a second time last year after being inducted into the Rock &amp, Roll Hall of Fame in 2006.

He previously celebrated his home city in 2022 when he helped close the Commonwealth Games.

Through their reality TV series The Osbournes, he gained even more fame alongside his wife Sharon, who he wed in 1982 and who has three children, Aimee, Jack, and Kelly.

All profits from the July 5 show will go to charities including Cure Parkinson’s, Birmingham Children’s Hospital and Acorn Children’s Hospice, which is supported by Aston Villa.

Continue reading the article.

Court rules against Trump’s use of Alien Enemies Act to deport Venezuelans

A judge in the United States has quashed President Donald Trump’s administration’s ability to deport Venezuelans from South Texas in violation of the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 (AEA).

The decision on Thursday is the first of its kind, and it is likely to face a swift appeal.

As Trump seeks to remove undocumented immigrants from the country quickly, it follows similar, if temporary, orders barring the government from using the law.

Judge Fernando Rodriguez Jr., a judge in the US District Court, ruled that the Trump administration had “exceeded the statutory boundaries” of the Alien Enemies Act, a wartime law.

On March 15, Trump signed an executive order to impose sanctions on Tren de Aragua members of Venezuela. He argued that Tren de Aragua was “propagandizing an invasion of and predatory incursion into the United States,” which supported such extreme measures.

After all, only three times before, most recently during World War II, were the Alien Enemies Act invoked.

However, Judge Rodriguez acknowledged that the gang engaged in behavior that “unambiguously is harmful to society” and that the threat of Tren de Aragua fell far short of the requirements for the Alien Enemies Act.

The judge wrote, “The Court concludes that Tren de Aragua’s activities do not fall within the plain, common definition of an invasion or a predatory incursion” in the context of the AEA.”

The Court rules that the President’s proclamation of the AEA goes beyond the meaning of the statute and is thus unlawful.

Judge Rodriguez ruled that the Trump administration could not “use the law” to “detain Venezuelan aliens, transfer them within the United States, or remove them from the country because they “did not possess the lawful authority under the AEA.”

Judge Rodriguez was appointed by Trump and served in his current capacity as a Republican leader in 2018. His decision affects Houston and the Southern District of Texas.

Although it is the most significant ruling of its kind, it also joins a number of court and legal decisions that evaluate the Trump administration’s use of Alien Enemies Act.

In times of war or invasion, the US government is authorized to detain and deport citizens of allies. However, its use has been highly polarized, with some calling it constitutional.

During World War II, the Alien Enemies Act was used as justification for the imprisonment of tens of thousands of Japanese Americans and other foreign nationals in camps. After the incident, decades later, the US officially apologized and offered compensation to Japanese American survivors.

The Alien Enemies Act is alleged to have been used by Trump as the first president to do so outside of combat. He has attempted to portray undocumented immigration to the US as an unchecked “invasion” of criminals who threaten US communities with violence by using nativist rhetoric.

Since taking office for a second term, Trump has labeled criminal organizations like Tren de Aragua as international terrorist organizations, making non-citizen members unadmissible in the US.

However, the Supreme Court has ruled (PDF) that foreigners have a right to judicial review of their cases when they are removed under the Alien Enemies Act.

Lower courts have also questioned whether the Trump administration’s use of the Alien Enemies Act violated that right to free speech.

Judges in Colorado, Manhattan, and Pennsylvania have temporarily enjoined the use of the law, and Judge James Boasberg in Washington, DC, has been in charge of a well-known case in which three planes deported from El Salvador were detained under the law despite an injunction against its use.

Boasberg ruled in favor of the Trump administration’s breach of his order last month, finding it to be “probable cause.” Boasberg has continued to face allegations in that case, but Trump and his allies claim that by interfering with foreign policy, he has overstepped his legal authority.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) applauded Judge Rodriguez’s decision on Thursday after being one of the plaintiffs who have filed lawsuits against the Alien Enemies Act’s use in court.

According to a statement from ACLU lawyer Lee Gelernt, the president can’t unilaterally invade the United States and invoke a wartime authority during peacetime. This 18th-century wartime law should never be used, according to Congress.

The ACLU’s Texas branch’s legal director Adriana Pinon also hailed the decision as a victory for immigrant rights.

“This permanent injunction is a significant win for preventing unlawful, unilateral executive action that has been stoking fear in Texas, especially within border communities,” she said.

“This state and nation are a largely a part of them,” said Immigrants, who have always been that way. Both US Constitution and US laws protect them.

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer also voiced his opposition, calling Trump’s use of the Alien Enemies Act unlawful.

Schumer wrote on social media that the Trump administration is “attempting to deport people without due process” and that it is “patently breaking the law.” Americans reject this, they say. They are being held accountable by the courts. We will continue to fight for our Constitution.