Palestinian rights activists praise New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani for reversing pro-Israel municipal laws within the first few hours of his inauguration, a move that the Israeli government swiftly condemned.
After Adams was charged with bribery on September 26, 2024, Mamdani removed all executive orders that his successor, Eric Adams, had implemented on his first day in office.
Recommended Stories
list of 3 itemsend of list
One of the orders forbids mayoral appointees from issuing contracts that “discriminate against the State of Israel, Israeli citizens, or those associated with” the US ally.
Its signing, which was less than a month old, was seen by critics as an attempt to stoke unrest in the incoming Mamdani administration.
The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), according to advocates, can be used to censor and punish anti-Semitism in a recently withdrawn decree, which was later withdrawn.
Israel and its supporters have long advocated for the “criminalization of dissent,” according to Nasreen Issa, a member of the Palestine Youth Movement in NYC.
According to Issa, Mamdani’s rejection of this is a positive step in the direction of upholding Palestinians’ rights, Issa said.
Mamdani’s revoking of an “unconstitutional order restricting the ability of New Yorkers to criticize the Israeli government’s racism or boycott Israel’s human rights abuses” was also applauded by Afaf Nasher, the head of the Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR)’s New York chapter.
According to Nasher, “This unconstitutional, Israel First attack on free speech should never have been made,” Nasher said in a statement.
Nasher criticized the IHRA definition further, claiming that “overly broad” guidelines categorize Zionism as anti-Semitism.
According to Nasher, the decree would have also proscribed boycotts against Israel that were only constitutional.
The IHRA definition, which focuses primarily on Israel, has long been opposed by Palestinian rights supporters. The definition lists 11 anti-Semitism instances, six of which involve Israel.
They include “applying double standards” to Israel and “claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor.”
YL Al-Sheikh, a Palestinian-American writer active in the Democratic Socialists of America, praised Mayor Mamdani’s decision on day one to strengthen our right to free speech, which included our right to criticize and oppose Israeli apartheid and genocide.
The IHRA’s implementation as government policy should not be about stifling dissent, which all Americans oppose.
Israel weighs in.
Mamdani’s actions were condemned by the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Friday, claiming that the newly elected mayor is “showing his true face.”
Not leadership, this. In a post on the social media platform X, it read, “It’s antisemitic gasoline on an open fire.”
In a separate statement, Amichai Chikli, Israel’s minister of diaspora affairs, criticized Mamdani’s decision using Islamophobic language.
He identified himself as the “Hamas sympathiser” and made contact with Sadiq Khan, the Muslim mayor of London.
These are exactly the choices you make when a Muslim Brotherhood Islamist with the slogan “Globalize the Intifada” takes control of New York City or London,” Chikli wrote on X.
There are no known ties between Mamdani and Khan regarding the Muslim Brotherhood.
Issa claimed that the mayor’s aggressive response to Israel is aimed more at enshrine the narrative rather than at influencing the mayor’s decisions.
“Israel’s main approach has been to push for the criminalization of protected speech through these warped definitions of anti-Semitism like the IHRA,” she said at the highest level and at the Foreign Ministry’s level.
The current response is to push for the criminalization of dissention because they are losing in the court of public opinion.
Issa also referred to Chikli’s attack on Mamdani as “blatant Islamophobia, racism, and disinformation.”
According to Issa, “They’re trying to spread these accusations that have no basis in reality,”
“From their perspective, nothing is acceptable about any support for Palestinians, any opposition to Israel’s genocide, or any military actions taken in Gaza or the West Bank over the past two years, or over the past decades.”
Al-Sheikh criticized Israel’s attempts to impose its preferences on local government in New York as “absurd.”
Al-Sheikh said, “Even Americans who aren’t Palestinian or pro-Palestine can see this is strange and restricts our rights.”
“It’s also oddly counterproductive on Israel’s part because Mamdani only gets better with it. The universal American position is that you should be allowed to criticize any country you want, not a country, according to a single policy paper that said you couldn’t criticize a nation.
However, Israel was not the only country to criticize Mamdani’s deeds. The Mamdani administration received a warning from the president’s administration, according to the Trump administration.
The Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division’s assistant attorney general, Harmeet Dhillon, stated that her office would be watchful of “AT ANY AND ALL CRIME BREACHES” in New York.
In a social media post, Dhillon stated, “We will investigate, sue, and indict as necessary.”
Palestinian solidarity activists frequently reaffirm the importance of denying Israeli violations as a justification for Judaism.
Mamdani’s rise
Mamdani has voiced her opposition to Israeli policies against Palestinians, drawing criticism from Israel’s supporters.
However, he has made a number of promises to keep Jewish people safe. He stated at the time of his inauguration that the Mayor’s Office to Combat Anti-Semitism (MOCA), an Adams-era development, would continue and that his administration would “celebrate and cherish” Jewish New Yorkers.
At the beginning of the new year, the 34-year-old mayor became the first Muslim mayor of the largest city in America to take the oath of office on a copy of the Quran.
When he first made his candidacy announcement late in 2024, the Democratic socialist, who formerly served as a state legislator, had little recognition for his name.
But as his message on affordability and housing steadily expanded, he gradually gained more support.
In one of the most stunning political upsets in recent US history, he defeated former governor Andrew Cuomo to win the Democratic nomination.
After the former governor relaunched his campaign as an independent with Trump’s support, Mamdani then defeated Cuomo once more in the November general elections.
Adams was a Democrat in 2021, but during its four-year tenure, his administration was accused of engaging in a quid pro quo with Turkish government representatives.
Trump’s federal bribery charges were dropped by the Justice Department earlier in 2024. Before the elections, Adams had begun a campaign for independent re-election, but he ultimately abandoned his campaign and supported Cuomo.
Some of Mamdani’s supporters claim that his vocal support for Palestinian rights helped to propel his campaign in the wake of Israel’s growing hostility toward Gaza, despite the platform’s largely local issues.