R360 ‘would be death knell for club rugby around the world’

Getty Images
  • 17 Comments

Sale co-owner Michelle Orange says the proposed new R360 competition risks killing off club rugby around the world if it gets off the ground.

R360, fronted by former England centre Mike Tindall, aims to launch in October, after a recruitment drive to sign star names for eight men’s teams and four women’s teams who will compete on an F1-style circuit of events in major world cities.

However, Orange says she and fellow owners would withdraw from rugby rather than become R360 feeder clubs.

“We’re certainly not going to keep investing all that money into building a pathway, only for Mike Tindall every three or four years…to take the cream off the top of the milk again.

“I’m not saying the Curry boys [Sale and England flankers Tom and Ben] are going to 360 – I’m just using them as an example – but if they went, by the time they retire, Mike Tindall’s going to need to replace them and keep expecting me to replace them within my squad.

“Most clubs are being supported by wealthy individuals who love the sport, want to do their bit for the sport, but certainly aren’t that stupid to keep putting money in to creating a conveyor belt that’s going to fund R360 and get no compensation for it.”

R360’s organisers claim it will soon turn a profit, by drawing in fans who watch Test rugby but don’t follow the current club game, as well as attracting new audiences.

It views its recruitment of overseas stars as no different from the sort of policy pursued by Japan’s top-tier clubs.

All Blacks fly-half Richie Mo’unga and South Africa’s two-time world player of the year Pieter-Steph du Toit are among those attracted to Japan Rugby League One by high wages and low workloads.

However, publicly at least, R360 is yet to make significant headway in building its roster.

Tom CurryGetty Images

Eight leading Test nations have issued a blanket ban on R360 recruits representing their national teams, wrecking hopes the rebel tournament had of allowing its players to combine the venture with international careers.

World Rugby is also yet to sanction R360 after asking for more information about the start-up’s plans.

Tom Curry, speaking in September, reaffirmed his own commitment to Sale.

“The investment from Simon and Michelle [Orange] and Ged Mason, we’re in a very fortunate position where we are in Manchester,” he said. “Nothing would get me away from that.”

England’s top flight has been optimistic that it can slowly move away from individual benefactors covering losses from their own pockets.

Mike TindallGetty Images

Orange says the impact of R360 would be most keenly felt in the women’s game however, with England’s Premiership Women’s Rugby (PWR), which hosts big-name talent from around the world, particularly vulnerable.

“I think it would absolutely kill the women’s game off,” Orange added.

“I completely understand why any international player would want to join R360. When you look at what these girls are earning as wages now, it’s still paltry compared to what the men get.

“And we’re not going to be in a position for several years to even start thinking about those wages going up dramatically – just because there’s not the money in the game.

“I don’t want to ever deprive an athlete from going to earn better money for themselves, they deserve it.

“But Mike Tindall is going to need a minimum of 120 to 140 players to join his league to make it successful for the four female franchises.

“If you take 140 girls out of the PWR , it would decimate us.

    • 16 October
    • 10 September
    • 10 November

It has been speculated that rugby league duo Zac Lomax and Ryan Papenhuyzen are destined for R360, after the pair walked away from unfulfilled NRL contracts with Parramatta Eels and Melbourne Storm respectively.

“I feel sorry for Zac, I feel sorry for Ryan Papenhuyzen, I think they’re being ill-advised and they’re jeopardising their whole careers on wild promises,” said Australian Rugby League Commission chair Peter V’landys earlier this week.

“What I would be strongly recommending to them is to get irrevocable bank guarantees that they will actually get paid.

“Anyone can make wild promises. Nobody has done any due diligence on any business model.”

Related topics

  • Sale
  • Rugby Union

More on this story

    • 1 day ago
    Elliot Daly

Stone Roses’ Mani was ‘itching’ to get back on stage just weeks before his death

Just weeks before his tragic death, Stone Roses legend Mani revealed he was excited to get back onto the stage and had been inspired by Oasis

Gary ‘ Mani ‘ Mounfield was “itching to get back” into music, he revealed in one of his final interviews just last month. Speaking in mid-October, Mani had said he had recently been to his lock-up and looked at his bass guitars and was being encouraged by other musicians to pick it up again.

He also may have been inspired by Oasis, having seen them a number of times on tour this year before his sad death. Former Stone Roses and Primal Scream bass player Mani said just weeks ago: “I’m in a great space at the moment. Itching to get back bro. I’m ready to get back”.

He added: “Johnny Marr’s always trying to get me to do stuff. Liam (Gallagher) was always trying to get me involved with stuff before the Oasis thing. I’m feeling now that I could pick up again, you know?. I’ve been in the lock up having a look at stuff and weeding out my collection”.

READ MORE: Mani from Stone Roses dead: Updates as Liam Gallagher leads tributes to iconREAD MORE: Liam Gallagher ‘in shock’ as Stone Roses’ Mani tragically dies

Mani was speaking on The Rockonteurs podcast in an interview which was published on October 19. He told hosts Gary Kemp and Guy Pratt he had seen Oasis four times on the current world tour, including one date at Wembley with fellow Stone Roses guitarist John Squire and was also in regular contact with Ian Brown via WhatsApp.

On the gigs he said: “They’re better now than ever, There’s not as much chaos and madness surrounding it and it becomes something with the benefit of a bit of age and y’know maturity”.

In the podcast he also spoke of how he became a bass player in the first place, which was not the first instrument he picked up. He said: “I came late to the bass guitar.

” I was a rhythm guitar player for years, and when the option arose to get on the bass, I jumped on it. And my musical tastes have always been from reggae and funk and soul, and even going back to like, Chris Hillman, I love from The Birds is one of my favourites.

Asked about his choice of bass guitar, he said: “Well, I just love Rickenbacker basses, because I’m a real fan of 60s stuff. And The Birds, the bands from that era, them and Hendrix and The Who and The Kinks. I love all that”.

Today, Gary’s nephew shared a heartbreaking announcement on social media confirming the sad news. He said: “Unfortunately with sad news my uncle Gary Mani Mounfield from the stone roses has sadly passed away today.

” Thinking of his twins and my uncle Greg at this sad time. He will be reunited in heaven with his lovely wife Imelda RIP Manni Your annoying nephew. “

Article continues below

Gary’s brother, Greg, added: “It is with the heaviest of hearts that I have to announce the sad passing of my brother, Gary Manu Mounfield.” Famous faces have also paid tribute, with Liam Gallagher writing on X, formerly known as Twitter: “In total shock and absolutely devastated on hearing the news about Mani many hero. RIP RKID LG.”

Ian Brown, lead singer of The Stone Roses, penned:” Rest In Peace Mani x. “

Stone Roses’ Mani was ‘itching’ to get back on stage just weeks before his death

Just weeks before his tragic death, Stone Roses legend Mani revealed he was excited to get back onto the stage and had been inspired by Oasis

Gary ‘Mani’ Mounfield was “itching to get back” into music, he revealed in one of his final interviews just last month. Speaking in mid-October, Mani had said he had recently been to his lock-up and looked at his bass guitars and was being encouraged by other musicians to pick it up again.

He also may have been inspired by Oasis, having seen them a number of times on tour this year before his sad death. Former Stone Roses and Primal Scream bass player Mani said just weeks ago: “I’m in a great space at the moment. Itching to get back bro. I’m ready to get back.”

He added: “Johnny Marr’s always trying to get me to do stuff. Liam (Gallagher) was always trying to get me involved with stuff before the Oasis thing. I’m feeling now that I could pick up again, you know?. I’ve been in the lock up having a look at stuff and weeding out my collection.”

READ MORE: Mani from Stone Roses dead: Updates as Liam Gallagher leads tributes to iconREAD MORE: Liam Gallagher ‘in shock’ as Stone Roses’ Mani tragically dies

Mani was speaking on The Rockonteurs podcast in an interview which was published on October 19. He told hosts Gary Kemp and Guy Pratt he had seen Oasis four times on the current world tour, including one date at Wembley with fellow Stone Roses guitarist John Squire and was also in regular contact with Ian Brown via WhatsApp.

On the gigs he said: “They’re better now than ever, There’s not as much chaos and madness surrounding it and it becomes something with the benefit of a bit of age and y’know maturity.”

In the podcast he also spoke of how he became a bass player in the first place, which was not the first instrument he picked up. He said: “I came late to the bass guitar.

“I was a rhythm guitar player for years, and when the option arose to get on the bass, I jumped on it. And my musical tastes have always been from reggae and funk and soul, and even going back to like, Chris Hillman, I love from The Birds is one of my favourites.

Asked about his choice of bass guitar, he said: “Well, I just love Rickenbacker basses, because I’m a real fan of 60s stuff. And The Birds, the bands from that era, them and Hendrix and The Who and The Kinks. I love all that.”

Today, Gary’s nephew shared a heartbreaking announcement on social media confirming the sad news. He said: “Unfortunately with sad news my uncle Gary Mani Mounfield from the stone roses has sadly passed away today.

“Thinking of his twins and my uncle Greg at this sad time. He will be reunited in heaven with his lovely wife Imelda RIP Manni Your annoying nephew.”

Article continues below

Gary’s brother, Greg, added: “It is with the heaviest of hearts that I have to announce the sad passing of my brother, Gary Manu Mounfield.” Famous faces have also paid tribute, with Liam Gallagher writing on X, formerly known as Twitter: “In total shock and absolutely devastated on hearing the news about Mani many hero. RIP RKID LG.”

Ian Brown, lead singer of The Stone Roses, penned: “Rest In Peace Mani x.”

Al Murray’s heartbreaking plea after 8-year-old nephew’s tragic death

The Pub Landlord’s Al Murray is urging members of the public to sign up for stem cell transplants after the tragic death of his eight-year-old nephew Finley Relf

Al Murray hasn’t stopped making us laugh since bursting onto the comedy scene as the Pub Landlord in the ‘90s. Behind the scenes, however, the comic has been dealing with the heartbreaking death of his eight-year-old nephew Finley Relf, with his family approaching the fourth anniversary of his passing.

Finley was diagnosed with juvenile myelomonocytic leukaemia – an aggressive and rare form of the childhood cancer – at the age of six. After two years of chemotherapy and stem cell transplants, Finley tragically died in 2021.

“He was lovely, boisterous and into monsters,” Al tells us. “He used to say that the best thing about riding a bike uphill was coming back down and going, ‘Wee!’ He was a bright and sweet boy – and very, very stoic because he was ill for a very long time.

“He was in and out of Great Ormond Street and Brighton Hospital. Seeing what my in-laws have been through, what my family has been through, losing a child. It’s horrible – you wouldn’t wish it on anybody.”

With Finley’s illness coinciding with the COVID-19 pandemic, it was even harder for his parents and wider family to visit him in the hospital.

“It was very, very difficult,” Al says. “My wife would go to see him every day at Great Ormond Street when he was there. He was immunocompromised, and he was in isolation. It was very difficult to see him and to keep his morale up.”

While battling the illness, Finley received three stem cell transplants, which allowed him to live for longer. “The only known effective cure is a stem cell transplant and he had a couple of those,” Al says.

“In the end, they didn’t work but they kept him going a lot longer than he would have kept going anyway. If people can get themselves on the stem cell register, if they come up as a match, they could save someone’s life.”

Since Finley’s death, Al has dedicated his time to raising awareness of stem cell transplants – working with charity Anthony Nolan to encourage others to sign up.

“When he died, I very much felt, ‘What can I do with my modicum of notoriety as it were?’ Advocating for stem cell donation seems like the right way to go.

“It’s not like giving blood where you have to give blood. With this, you get your DNA on the database, they know who you are and if they need you, they call you. I think it’s brilliant. It’s not just kids but it’s everybody that you might save.”

During his life, Finley received stem cell donations from all over the world – and Al stresses that the more data on the system, the better chances there are of finding a match.

“He had a German donation that they used to call Herman and then he had an American donor as well,” he says. “It’s a truly international effort. It’s a match like a fingerprint almost, it’s much more precise than blood type. You need as close a genetic match as you can possibly get – that’s why we need more people.

“We also need more people of different ethnic backgrounds because quite simply, the numbers are stacked against you in a Western country like this if you’re from an ethnic background.”

After Finley’s death, his parents set up their own charity in his honour to help parents of other ill children through the process. “It’s called Finley’s Touch and raises money for families in that situation,” he says.

“They provide what they call a hospital survivor bag, which has coffee, WiFi vouchers, books and toys. Going into that sort of ward is very hard going. Your life is put completely on hold. Lots of people have to quit work because they’ve got to be with their kids.”

Now, Al and his family try to help others after Finley’s horrific battle. “It was just an awful, stressful time for everybody. I’ve been sort of adjacent to it so seeing what my brother-in-law and his wife went through and Finn’s brother as well, it is extremely tough.

“It’s a hellish and bitter, horrible illness that’s remorseless. We try not to dwell on that time and to think what we can do out the other side,” he adds. “Being a stem cell donor is your chance to save someone’s life. It’s like the lottery in a strange way.

“You buy a ticket by getting on the register, you might win and save someone’s life – so why not buy a ticket?”

In the meantime, Al has been keeping busy by planning a TV return as the Pub Landlord and hosting his podcast, WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk. However, his fans have rallied around Finley’s charity and raised over £10,000 for the cause.

“The listeners to my podcast have completely mobilized themselves around the charity and have raised a ton of money by going on marches and doing sponsored walks and doing events,” he says. “It’s been genuinely boggling.

“We keep being told that the world is chaotic and selfish and horrible. But actually, it doesn’t strike me when I see that and people’s efforts that it is at all. People are good.”

Article continues below

Al Murray is working with stem cell transplant charity Anthony Nolan, which recently opened a new cell collection centre in Nottingham.

If you have been affected by this story, advice and support can be found at childbereavementuk.org or you can call them on 0800 02 888 40.

‘I made mistakes on TV, he made his on a field’ – Panesar responds to Smith

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.

Former England spinner Monty Panesar has responded to Steve Smith’s bizarre swipe at him by saying he made his mistakes “on a quiz show”, while the stand-in Australia captain “made his on a cricket field”.

Speaking on the eve of the first Ashes Test in Perth, Smith ridiculed Panesar, saying anyone who thought “Athens is in Germany” or “Oliver Twist is a season” should not be taken seriously.

But referring again to the ball-tampering scandal against South Africa in 2018 that led to Smith’s sacking as Australian captain, Panesar told Radio 5 Live: “I’ve had some great moments for England and I’ve had shockers, and he’s had some great moments for Australia and he’s obviously had a very big shocker in South Africa.

“We’ve both made mistakes. I made mine on a quiz show, he made his on a cricket field.”

The spat followed comments to a gambling website from the 43-year-old last week on how England should make Smith feel “guilty” about his part in the ‘Sandpapergate’ incident, where Australia’s “leadership group” had a plan, carried out by Cameron Bancroft, to tamper with the ball to “get an advantage”.

Smith, 36, has often been taunted by fans over the scandal.

And he brought up Panesar’s Mastermind episode, calling it “pretty comical”, when responding to the ex-bowler’s views.

“Anyone who believes that Athens is in Germany, Oliver Twist is a season of the year, and America is a city, it doesn’t really bother me those comments,” Smith said in his pre-match news conference.

With Pat Cummins out with a back injury, Smith will lead Australia in the first Test, which begins at Perth Stadium on Friday.

And Panesar, who played 50 Tests between 2006 and 2013, added: “What makes it more sort of pleasing is that the night before the Test match, he’s watching my Mastermind clips, memorising the questions and the answers.

The Ashes: Australia v England

Listen on SoundsWatch on iPlayer

Time for England ‘to really go hard at’ Smith

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.

Panesar admitted he was “surprised” by Smith’s decision to bring up his appearance on Celebrity Mastermind, saying he expected a more measured response from the Australian batsman.

The 43-year-old had correctly answered six questions on Sikhism and its history in the specialist subject round of the show.

“I think everyone from my media friends, to everyone in the media, have said they couldn’t believe Smith kind of responded in that way,” added Panesar.

“I thought everyone thought it would have been just a bit more, ‘right it’s OK, yeah fine, I cheated, it’s not a problem, I’ve moved on from that, it’s not an issue’.

“But because he’s done it in this way, I think he’s kind of opened up now for the England boys to really sort of go hard at him, play a few mind games with him and that could be the difference where he gets out early.

“And suddenly they’ll be sort of saying thanks Monty for just trying to engage in that conversation, of maybe seeing if you talk about sandpaper will it make him feel a little bit guilty or not?

“Look, I know I’m guilty of bad general knowledge but not ball-tampering. And I’ll take that everyday.”

Luton-born Panesar, who played for Sussex, Essex and Northamptonshire in his county career, was part of the England side that won the 2009 Ashes series.

Getty Images

Related topics

  • England Men’s Cricket Team
  • Australia
  • The Ashes
  • Cricket

More on this story

    • 16 August
    BBC Sport microphone and phone